Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Dialectics of Representation in Xose Neira Vilas'
Memorias dun neno labrego
Ana Carballal
University of Nebraska-Omaha
Galicia, the northwestern region of Spain that fought for centuries for the
preservation of its cultural and literary identity, saw the renaissance of its
literature in the second half of the nineteenth century. Since then, this area
has produced an impressive number of intellectuals and writers who have used
the Galician language and culture as the mark of their books and whose work
of recovery and promotion has situated it as one of the best-known regions
in Spain and in Europe. One of these writers, Xosé Neira Vilas, has had
a life of struggles and many accomplishments as a Galician and defender of the
Galician culture, identity, and history. Born in the little village of Gres
in Pontevedra in 1928, he had to emigrate very early (in 1949) to America in
search of a better life and future, as did many of his contemporaries. In
Argentina he met and began a friendship with some of the most prominent
writers and nationalists of this time, including Luis Seoane, Lorenzo
Varela, Ramón Suárez Picallo, and Rafael Dieste.1
They would influence his life's purpose and his writings.
In Argentina, Neira Vilas met his wife Anisia Miranda, and together they
founded the organization Mocedades galegas [Galician Youth], a group that
worked for the promotion of Galician literature and culture to younger
generations, for the recovery of the Galician language, and for the revival
of cultural and political identity after the Spanish Civil War. He also
founded a publishing house, Follas Novas, which was the first distributor
of Galician literature outside this region (Rábade 8-9). The creative
genius of Neira Vilas gave light to many books of poetry, prose, and short
stories. Among his works, it is important to highlight the poetry collection
Dende lonxe [From Afar] (1960), the novels Xente no rodicio
[People in the Millstone] (1965), Camiño bretemoso
[Nebulous Road] (1967), A muller de ferro [The Iron Lady]
(1969), and what is called "the child cycle," a group of three novels: Memorias
dun neno labrego [Memories of a Farm Boy] (1961), Cartas a Lelo
[Letters to Lelo] (1971), and Aqueles anos do Moncho [Those years
of Moncho] (1977), in which the protagonists, always children, perceive the
hard reality of Galicia in the 1950s and '60s.
Memorias dun neno labrego is considered one of the best-known and most
widely read novels of Galician literature, having 23 editions subsequent to its
initial publication in 1961 (Alonso 13). The novel tells the childhood experiences
of Balbino, a poor boy brought up in Galicia's countryside, whose candid and deep
perception of reality puts the reader in contact with the problems of the people
living in this land in the mid-twentieth century. In his brief journal, Balbino
-- writing for himself but also, as Maria Lucas and Dolores Vilavedra (A
recepción 32-33) affirm, writing for an imaginary and benevolent
audience that will identify with him -- describes his life in the country,
commenting on the injustices of his situation.
He lives with his parents, brother, and aunt. The very poor family survives
by working the land for the village boss who takes advantage of them, renting
the land for a very high price and taking the majority of their harvest. At the
same time, for the smallest problem, he threatens to fire them, pressing Balbino's
family to put up with his abuse. Through his innocent though keen eyes, Balbino
observes all these injustices and criticizes the incongruent customs and practices
that have been imposed for centuries in Galicia, leaving the people under the yoke
of slavery created by the government of a few. The protagonist notices how the
more the village boss threatens his family with eviction, the more his father
gives in and submits to his abuse. Balbino also rejects the customs imposed by
the Catholic Church regarding mourning, the respect to authority, and the persecution
of foreign ideas because the Church leaves peasants ignorant, narrow-minded, and at
the will of their bosses.
According to Rábade Paredes, in Vilas' stories about children, the main
objective is to make his readers aware of the loneliness and isolation facing his
young protagonists and to extend an invitation to stop it:
a insolidariedade, a incomprensión e crueldade do mundo dos adultos; a
presencia opresiva da vila sobre o agro; a explotación e aellamento que
a esfera do oficial opera nos humildes; o sometemento xordo ó traballo que
escraviza; o aniquilamento da expresión cultural propia polo imperio da
dominación allea; a institución castradora do cacique; e, en fin,
a presentación dun país hábilmente cultivado para o atraso
moral e material, para a sumisión e a permanencia na injusticia, son
algúns dos problemas que ante os lectores formula Neira Vilas.... (18)
[the conflict, the incomprehension and cruelty of the adult world; the oppressive
presence of the city over the countryside; the exploitation and isolation that the
official sphere imposes over the humble; the uncontested submission to enslaving
work; the annihilation of one's own cultural expression by the empire of foreign
domination; the castrating institution of the tyrant; and, at last, the presentation
of a country that has been easily trained for its own moral and material backwardness,
for its submission to and acceptance of injustice, these are some of the problems
that Neira Vilas presents his readers....]
The most important proclamation of the book is Balbino's resolution not to be tamed
or overcome by this loneliness and desperation but to fight against the system and
his family to free himself from all conventions and be able to make his own future.
He sees the differences and injustices, and although he is too little to do anything
about them, he criticizes the prejudices that permeate his small world and Galician
society in the 1950s.
For Fernández Del Riego, this work was a first and painful expression of the
experiences that the author experienced while a child (285), and for Alonso Montero,
it was a sort of Galician Marxist Manifesto. Montero views Balbino as an intellectual
child. Balbino did not go to school for very long, never went to the university, but
questions everything: traditions, characters, what people say, how they act. Without
ever having heard of Marx, he has a very clear sense of class and social difference.
He knows that in society there are the wealthy and the poor and that his family
belongs to the latter. He is aware of class oppression and of the church impositions;
however, he rejects the assumption that the poor should submit to this abuse (14-15).
Following this analysis of the protagonist as a leftist and his acknowledgement of
the beliefs that mark his community and Galicia in general, another perspective that
should be taken into account in the analysis of this work is the influence of these
beliefs as a text through which to establish the will of those in power.
In his work The Political Unconscious, Fredric Jameson affirms that there is
no such thing as a nonbiased, new reading of a text. Any kind of text, written or
painted, social or political, has always been read before and interpreted for us.
That means that any text, besides having the capacity of being an instrument of
ideological control and propaganda, will always remain a tool to preserve the status
quo through the reverberation of infinite interpretations that will institute the
"correct" apprehension of its meaning: "Texts come before us as the
always-already-read; we apprehend them through sedimented layers of previous
interpretations, or -- if the text is brand-new -- through the sedimented reading
habits and categories developed by those inherited interpretative traditions" (9).
For Jameson, texts have a given reading upon which all readers base their
interpretation. No interpretation is free from the intellectual and, more
specifically, the social and economic context in which it was created. This use
of texts as ideological instruments confers the importance of their being the
transmitters and modulators of reality, of how things are and even should be.
In this context, the concept of the political unconscious, the idea that
institutionalized texts are commonly accepted and internalized through the
unconscious, will help to expose the elements through which the novel and its
protagonist challenge the institutionalized reality. Within the narrative, the
different levels of representation will infringe upon the imposed order and the
various positions given to each person by authority, society, and history, with
the aim of challenging the vision that authorities have about Galicia and its
inhabitants. Thus Galicia, as a written, visual, political, social, or even a
conceptual idea, is regarded in Memorias dun neno labrego, as the most
important text of all.
In the novel, the official idea of Galicia is constantly contested by many of
the characters, the most important being Manolito, the Jew and in some ways
Manolito's godfather, who does not agree with the idea that living in any other
land, particularly America, would be better for this region and its inhabitants.
Nevertheless, Galicia as a text is continuously presented in this book as the
stereotypical poorest region of Spain, ignored by politicians and without any
great role in history. It is the constantly forgotten province that comes under
the shadow of the rest of the regions in political and economic relevance. This
representation, what Jameson called the "false consciousness," is established
on the basis of the dominant class ideologies and broken when the lower classes,
the proletariat, identify with their own class and end up overthrowing the
bourgeoisie. Nevertheless, as Jameson also states, it is very difficult to
attain this state of things when, historically, that dominant ideology was
the only one existent and the one used by everybody to determine their identity
and position in society (283). As an example of the influence of this dominant
class, there are for instance the works of historians such us John Hooper, who
says Galicia is an area with frequent famines that has streets of major cities
filled with "semi naked walking skeletons" (421), an area that was "victim of
the dynamics of Spanish history," depending always on the central government of
Castile but without being a part of it. Likewise, Angel Smith and Javier Tussell
show poverty, oppression and immigration as the main characteristics of Galicia
in the nineteenth century and the beginning of the twentieth century. Smith
states how, at this time,
the region was one of the poorest of Spain. Agricultural development was
hampered by the small scale structure of much of the land. Tiny plots, known
as minifundios, dominated the landscape and made it increasingly difficult
for the peasantry to subsist on the land.... The backward agrarian nature of much
of Galicia meant that it was ideal territory for the caciques of the Cánovas
Restoration. It was also to remain a relative stronghold of the Catholic Church.
(180)
Tussell, referring to the migratory process at the beginning of the twentieth
century and the segments of the population that were part of it, concludes that
"La mayoría procedían de regiones con una alta densidad de población
y una falta de recursos económicos como, por ejemplo era el caso de Galicia"
["The majority came from regions with a high density of population and a shortage
of economic resources as, for instance, was the case in Galicia"] (572). Xelis de
Toro confirms that "Galicia has in some senses been obliterated from the cultural
map, due to the failure to create a cohesive and integrated national identity. As
a result, Galicia continues to be characterized in the rest of Spain by a series
of clichés and stereotypes" (346). These representations, while guarding
a parallel to the one in Memorias dun neno labrego, are part of this "false
consciousness." They are the vision of an all-powerful authority whose repressive
ideology seeks as an objective to preserve a society of blinded individuals who
cannot see their potential as a group and who live in a permanent state of
unprovoked contentment. Given an image of poverty and powerlessness in the
novel, Galicia's social groups work to fulfill this image.
In Memorias dun neno labrego, this region is considered a land of peasants
and fishermen whose lives depend on their masters' wishes and plans while their
own initiatives and values are worthless. Peasants are portrayed as dominated by
a few individuals with power, who in some cases are not even Galician but represent
interests and perceptions that are believed to make up the real characteristics of
these people. These peasants cannot overcome the mistreatment of their masters.
They have the desire to do it, but, as Jameson contends, the future's uncertainty
and change prevent them from taking the next step. It is then how these peasants
live under the fear that if they break the rules, if they question the bosses'
decisions and dare stand up against injustices, annihilation will fall upon them.
In some ways, Galicia is once more portrayed as the land of skeletons that Hooper
referred to. These skeletons are the result of famines, of domination, and of
lack of systems that may prevent exploitation.
In the minds of the peasants, rules are presented as necessary for society's
self-government and used by the few to mold all the rest of the groups to compliance
under the fear of class extinction. These "official interpretations" and
understandings govern society for an indefinite period of time until a group or
individual recognizes the fraud and dares to challenge them (30-34). And this is
what is required to happen in Balbino's world. Balbino's account of his life and
experiences plays with the conscious and unconscious levels of representation to
criticize the unjust class stratification that leaves Galician peasants as slaves
to the former feudal nobility and rising bourgeoisie. Following Jameson's concept,
the narrative of Memorias dun neno labrego shows the mechanisms through which social
consciousness represses all historical contradictions and portrays a surface under
which unbearable forces are in constant danger of exploding.
According to Jameson, social consciousness (as the unspoken, unacknowledged set
of rules that govern social conceptions and interactions) is created in any society
composed by groups where collective norms are established by the upper classes.
Given that the separation of that society into different strata is a mere illusion
generated by those on top, the history and premises that brings this society into
existence are always under suspicion and full of contradictions that the less
privileged classes will tolerate but also will continuously question:
the very content of a class ideology is relational, in the sense that its "values"
are always actively in situation with respect to the opposing class, and defined
against the latter: normally, a ruling class ideology will explore various strategies
of the legitimation of its own power position. (84)
In Memorias dun neno labrego, this social consciousness is presented by the
family's boss, but more particularly by Balbino's family members who have already
internalized the social rules and behaviors that they have to keep to survive.
This consciousness is presenting Galicia once again as a country of peasants needing
the guidance of a master and the imposition of social, religious, political, and
economic systems that will structure reality and secure survival. That is why in
the first line of the novel, Balbino defines himself as "a nobody," offering several
reasons to explain this depiction. To begin with, he is a child, and later, under
the protection of his family, he is still without a voice. In addition, he sees
himself as a nobody because of his life in the countryside, in a little rural
community where he does not have access to the governmental or economic opportunities
that the big city could offer. As such, taking into consideration that all the
political and economic decisions were imposed by the government institutions seated
in the big cities, he doesn't have a voice within these decision-making entities
either. Finally, he is a farmer, a son of farmers, describing not only himself and
his family but all the farmers who live in little villages, work the land, give all
their earnings to their masters, and remain in the same state of poverty and
desperation. In this regard, then, Galicia, from the point of view of Balbino,
could be characterized as a country of nobodies.
Another characterization of Galicia that relates to the notion of this struggle
between classes and its ramifications is the peasants' fear of and submission to
any type of authority. María Lucas, in her examination of the topic of religion
in Memorias, characterizes the peasants' beliefs as a mixture of Catholic dogma
and superstition. They follow tradition, value and practice the different rituals, but
there is a lack of authenticity, shown through hypocrisy on the part of the people who
believe out of fear or obligation and not because they have true faith (81). One
example of this is the psychological make-up of Balbino's godmother. Born into the
ideology of the Catholic Church, this woman sees the entire world around her not as
a consequence of injustices and wrong choices but as part of a God-designed plan. She
fears the religious authorities; she lives to follow rules and keep appearances toward
the outside world. She tries to avoid any type of scandal or reproach that anybody may
accuse her of, and accordingly she demands scrupulous attention and commitment to the
religious traditions. In this context, when her husband passes away, she demands that
the entire family, including Balbino, mourn for three years: "Encambáronme o
loito hai tres anos e con él sigo, sen poder ir ás foliadas, nin vestirme
de vello no entroido. Nunca quixen arrepoñerme por non ver chorar á
madriña" ["They imposed on me the mourning three years ago, and I am still
wearing black, without being able to go to any parties or to dress up as an old man
during the Carnival. I never wanted to stand up to them because I didn't want to
make my godmother cry"] (49) In the same way, when Balbino's brother leaves to go
to America, the godmother orders him never to stop going to Sunday mass, while Balbino's
mother offers some prayers to the Virgin to ask for protection for her son. In the same
way, the mother wants Balbino to attend and pay attention to all the religious
processions: "Reza e mira para os santos" ["Pray and look at the saints"] (40). This
religious fervor is not entirely blind faith but the respect towards tradition and a
fear for religious authority with power to censor behaviors and get people into trouble
with the civil powers. Their influence is also a cause of fear.
One of the portraits of Galicia in the text is poverty and its dependence on the
wealthy and powerful to survive. Balbino sees himself as poor but also recognizes
the difference between his situation and the life of the son of the village boss,
Manolito. For others in the village, including Balbino's family, the fact that Manolito
is richer, spoiled, and rude is a given. Acting as the antagonist for Balbino, Manolito
eats white bread, dresses nicely, is always very clean, drinks coffee and milk, and does
not need to get up early to take the cows to the field. The protagonist, on the other
hand, is presented as one who has to accept his responsibilities, his position in society,
without questioning it. He has to agree with the fears of the adults, and he has to be
respectful and polite with everybody, especially Manolito, who is mean, rude, and beats
him up. In spite of all the abuse, what really troubles Balbino is the fact that every
adult around him, specifically his father, tries to justify this behavior and their own
submission to it: "É o neno do señor e abonda" ["He is the master's son
and that is enough reason"] (34). Balbino's family lives at the mercy of Manolito's
father and submits to his abuse.
Nevertheless, if Balbino has to accept who Manolito is and what he does to him,
this acceptance marks a contradiction between how the masters live in comparison to
everyone else. Opposing the lifestyle of Manolito, Balbino eats brown bread (which
is, strikingly, the cause of the ulcers in her mother's stomach) and does not have
nice clothes but has to save his good outfits and shoes for the most important
occasions to wear them. He describes, for instance, how in the summers he walks
without shoes when the stones burn his feet, while in the winter, he has to be in
the cold, taking care of the animals and dreaming about sitting beside a fire and
drinking a cup of soup with bread. This image that Balbino gives in his diary about
his life in the village and the fact that he considers himself a nobody is the light
that will lead him to believe in the feared revolution that Jameson talks about.
Balbino wants to be a practical, decisive instrument of his own life and
surroundings, but in his dismay, he states, "Os maiores cánsanse e fannos
calar.... Calamos. Porque é perigoso non calar a tempo. E calquera día
en calquera luga, facémoslle a pregunta a calquera" ["The adults get tired
and tell us to be quiet.... We keep quiet. It is dangerous not to shut up on time.
And on any given day, in any place we ask anybody the question"] (58).
Balbino, with a child's mind, is the first to see Galician problems and society
for what they are and the first to confront the fear of that society's political
unconscious: the fear of annihilation if they break with this slave-like situation.
Balbino observes how he himself, like any other person in the village, is part of
a system that cannot be challenged or changed but in which he has to fit without
questioning: "Tiven mágoa de min por ser un neno pobre. Os pobres de todo
que andan polas portas esfarrapados, e as veces ata rouban patacas ou millo para
comer, están mellor. Aturan ós de fora pero non ós da casa
que queren andar ben co amo" ["I was sad for being poor. The poor who have nothing,
they go from door to door, dirty, or steal potatoes or corn to eat, they are in
better situation than me. They have to put up with others but not with their
families who want to be on good terms with the master"] (34). The protagonist
cannot disagree with the way the elite behaves and functions since it is his own
family's decision to accept this situation and surrender to their ill-treatment.
Time and again in the novel, his family is portrayed as accomplice to their
own suffering. They make their decisions based on social and hierarchical
rules and expectations. This is what happens, for example, when Balbino runs
away from the holy week procession and ends up in one of the fields that belongs
to the "Jew." At the beginning of the story and because of the name given to this
character, one may assume that the prospective conflict may be one of a religious
nature of Catholics versus Jews; nevertheless, as the story develops, it is clear
that religion is only an excuse to criticize a hypocritical, undeveloped society
that is not able to transform itself and finds in all social depictions an excuse
to remain the same.
The character of the Jew is a portrait of the racial and ideological discrimination
of a person who dares to stand up to the social establishment. The "Jew," as he is
called by everybody in the village, is not obsessed with society's customs and
regulations and who likes to think for himself. He is discriminated against because
he does not follow the same religious convictions as everybody else, and he does
not care about following this nonsense in order to keep the social powers happy
and controlled. He observes how people go to church, trying to be on good terms
with the priest and to keep up appearances; however,
a xente que vai rezando tampouco atende o que fai. Uns cavilan no hórreo
valdeiro, na contribución, na peste das patacas; outros tecen no pensamento
as peores aduanadas, e sinten ata cobiza da roupa que poden levar os
demáis.... E se Deus é como din, xa debe ter arranxado un inferno
para todos os que lle fan burla desta maneira. (43)
[the people who pray do not normally pay attention to what they are doing. Some think
about the empty granary, about the taxes, about the potato plagues; others focus their
thoughts on how to do the worst harm and they even feel jealous because others are
wearing better clothes than them.... If God is the way they say, he must have already
prepared a hell for everyone who is making fun of him this way.]
The Jew has a rebellious nature. He rejects hypocrisy and deception and prefers to
see people for what they do, not what they say. This is why he values a person such
as the priest of Ribán, who teaches children catechism but also forces them to
learn geography, history, and agriculture. He sees this discrepancy between the people
who are consistent with their beliefs and the people who are not, and as in the case
of Balbino, he uses these inconsistencies to question the system.
These types of contradictions could be studied under what Jameson calls the
"ideological hegemony" or the contradiction of history. Societies, on their
basis, are formed succinctly by dominant classes who fight to keep the status
quo and avoid a revolution that will take them out of their privileged position
and, at the same time, the classes under them, who, with the same fear of losing
their positions of underdogs, agree to be the proletariat class and do not revolt:
"This suggests, to use another Hegelian formula, that the truth of ruling class
consciousness (that is, of hegemonic ideology and cultural production) is to be
found in working class consciousness" (290). As seen by the character of the Jew
in the novel, Galician peasants and workers strive in the same way to please the
authority in order to live in peace and avoid losing their exiguous benefits as
poor. In the story, Balbino sees the injustice that the owners of the land are
perpetrating against his family and others. Through his eyes, however, the readers
see a family and a village that submits so rapidly and conscientiously to the
ways of their masters, that they become not only part of that ideological hegemony
but its main contributors, enforcers, and supporters. That is why, when the Jew
questions Balbino about what he knows about him, he himself acknowledges that he
is the only one who is not imbedded in that church culture and that he feels pity
for those who think that their souls are patrimony of the priest: "A min tanto me
ten; sintóo por eles, que parecen ovelliñas en vez de homes e mulleres.
Cadaquén deulle a súa alma a gardar ó cura e o cura non fai mais
que estragarlla" ["It doesn't matter to me; I feel pity for them, they seem like little
lambs instead of men and women. Each one of them gave their soul to the priest to keep
and the priest does nothing except ruin it"] (44). The Jew lives outside the influence
of these hegemonic forces (his own choice, in spite of being considered an outsider
and shunned by everybody); nevertheless, one does not need outright to reject the
principles of the community to be rejected and have to leave. When Balbino's brother
leaves to go to America, these hegemonic forces are shown to be the ones that push
individuals to depart from their land and families to try to make it somewhere else.
Emigration, at least the type of emigration that forces the individual to leave for
a foreign country as the only means for survival, may be seen as another type of
slavery. When people go away, they have succumbed to the system, to the social
structure and expectations as imposed by the upper classes. These individuals are
defeated, and they have accepted their imaginary failure under those imaginary
conditions. That ideological hegemony again shows a portrait of Galicia as the
land of emigrants, and in many instances it is still considered such. According
to Xose Manuel Seixas, in the second half of the nineteenth century and first of
the twentieth, around 60% of the people who left Spain to go to America were from
Galicia. Emigration was not only a way to raise the opportunities for specific
individuals but the means to support Galicia economically and to make everybody
aware of the importance of its culture and values (11-12). Ofelia Rey Castelao
affirms that, although Galician presence abroad was minimal until the eighteenth
and nineteenth centuries, many Galicians were part of the ecclesiastical and
administrative elites that established the colonies, and it was not until the
nineteenth century when masses of poor peasants started to arrive in Argentina
and Cuba in search of better opportunities.
According to Alejandro Vázquez, José Carlos Moya, and María
Liliana da Orden, it was at the end of the nineteenth century and beginning of the
twentieth century when Galicia experienced the highest number of displacements.
In the mid 1800s, people started leaving because of a variety of reasons: the two
most important being the ill distribution of the land and economic resources, and
the fantastic news regarding the never-ending possibilities in the land of paradise
across the ocean (Vázquez 55-59). These displacements resulted in the
separation of families and, in some instances, the uprooting of men and women who,
leaving behind all they had, were going to take a chance and lose everything. In
more extreme cases, such as in Puerto Rico, according to Carmen Campos Esteve,
many businessmen and administrators became fully integrated in the culture and
economy of their new country (18-19). In Cuba also, there was an increase of
Galician immigrants mainly in the 1850s, many of whom, according to Paz Andrade,
were used to substitute for the African slaves who were on their path to freedom
(431).
In this regard, it is important to notice the conversation that Balbino's father
and godfather have concerning the people who leave to America and particularly
Balbino's brother Miguel who, at the beginning of the novel, is leaving the village.
In this conversation, two visions of Galicia reflect different adaptations to that
ideological hegemony. On one hand, we have the father, who conceives America as the
land of opportunity, where anybody can get rich if he works hard and knows how to
save his money. He sees some immigrants coming back to Galicia to buy land and houses
and living large, and he believes the "official" version of immigration that young
people want to see the world, get an education, know other cultures, and expand their
horizons. He is also afraid that Galicia and Spain are not going to have enough space
to hold all the people and, as a consequence, he approves emigration as the means to
get out of poverty and ignorance, even though he does not want all his children to
leave the paternal house.
In studies by Nora Longhini and Corinne Son, Neira Vilas is described as ambivalent
in his opinion on emigration. For Longhini, the author in all his works uses characters
who have gone abroad or still bear witness to the hardship and brokenness of emigration
(54). Corinne Son quotes the author's insights regarding his own experience as an
emigrant, affirming that it was simultaneously traumatic and beneficial. To emigrate
forces individuals to abandon families, language, and customs, but it also opens a
lot of possibilities for young people to become educated or ascend socially (88).
In spite of this positive vision of emigration, Neira Vilas, like many other Galician
writers, is trying to demystify Balbino's father's idea that everything is better
abroad. It is in this way that he uses the character of Balbino's godfather to
disassemble the mythical beliefs sustained by many Galician people that the wonderful
lands across the ocean are filled with gold, treasures, and easy living. For Balbino's
godfather if one works hard, he can survive without leaving the land, even in Galicia.
For the godfather, emigration is a trap created by the government and the upper classes
to impoverish the land, to get rid of the people, and increase their own possessions.
When somebody was going abroad, generally first he had to sell all his possessions to
come up with enough money for the trip and other expenses, and the land was usually
bought by the person with the most money in the village: the master or any other person
in authority who could possess a bank account. The master then would employ more laborers
to work the land and reap the fruit to the point that many villages in Galicia would
become old medieval manors, with one lord and many servants. Though some come back
rich, many do not make it financially, and some even die on the way to their new
countries. Immigrants lose their culture, their traditions, and the knowledge acquired
in their land, becoming not more worldly, as Balbino's father wants to believe, but
ignorant of customs and social structures of both their country of origin and their
new land. Nevertheless, what Balbino's godfather regrets the most is that while the
country of Galicia is running on empty and its only inhabitants are children and the
elderly, Galician youths are living and working in other countries, improving other
economies: "O país está sen exprotar. Se da noite para a
mañá non deixasen sair a ninguén, faríamos unha
revolución que é o que compre, e todos viviríamos como se merece
sen andar esmiñatando en terras alleas" ["In this country nobody works the
land. If one day they would not let anybody leave, we would make a revolution, that
is what this country needs, and everybody would live as they deserved, without going
out to work foreign lands"] (70). Balbino's godfather realizes that the problem with
Galician land and peasants is that the land is in the hands of a few, the new bourgeoisie
and the old nobility, who possess it but do not work on it. To work the land, they hire
cheap laborers who accept their condition as slaves in exchange for survival. Tired of
the slavery, the youngsters leave to look for a better life; however, that better life
will not be found abroad, and desperation and hopelessness brings about the only exit:
revolution.
During the novel and more clearly in the last part, that idea will be a constant in
the protagonist's mind. Because of his youth and sometimes his innocence, Balbino
asks daring questions that make him the challenger of the social order; they make
him confront that political unconsciousness and ideological hegemony for the first
(and one may suppose the last) time at the end of the novel. As part of this
confrontation, Balbino will see finally that what he is fighting against is not
a specific group of people but a fixed system of beliefs and accepted set of values
that must be transformed. This transformation will not be completely possible
because of that political unconscious that reinforces all the fears in the rest
of the characters in the novel and society in general. However, Balbino's stand
towards that system will shake the basis upon which it was formed and give him a
final escape.
This final revolution, as Balbino conceives it, is explained by what Jameson calls
the idea of "ideologeme," "nonsynchronous development," and "cultural revolution."
According to Jameson, "ideologeme" is the minimal unit around which a class discourse
is organized and a complete philosophical system or proto-narrative is established.
Ideologemes may contain themselves in what Jameson calls a "pseudoidea" or a system
of beliefs, opinions and prejudices, even in narratives in which the different classes
mirror their opposites (87). In Memorias, we have already seen different types,
the idea of possessing and working the land, the initiative to mourn and keep the
religious traditions, the belief that emigration is the way to escape poverty. Each
one of these instances may be considered an ideologeme.
The people of the village where Balbino resides were influenced throughout history
by the mindsets and traditions imposed on them by the institutions. Their
conceptualization takes place often in the novel when Balbino writes in his diary
and above all when he questions the system. That is the reason why he does not
understand how his father can respect the master, a cruel and despotic man who is
using them as slaves. In addition, Balbino rejects the idea that he cannot defend
himself when Manolito beats or spits on him. However, all these questions reinforce
a view of society that becomes the opposite of what the traditional government
organizations desire. The protagonist not only interacts with the oppressive forces
from which he seeks freedom, his family, Manolito's influence, the Church, and his
godmother, Balbino also has contacts with subversive voices (people and institutions),
including marginalized and non-conformist figures such as the Jew, the emigrants,
the undertakers and the Carnival goers. The Jew, for being an independent thinker,
the emigrants for having abandoned the land and the undertaker and carnival goers
for not following the "God fearing" traditions imposed by the Church and civil
authorities, will be seen as dissident and even radical.
This balance created by Balbino between social authorities and outcasts is at the
same time what is going to reflect the "nonsynchronous development." This term,
taken from Ernst Bloch's article on "Nonsynchronism and Dialectics," refers to the
different systematic levels of social intercourse that illustrate the simultaneous
functions of the different modes of production and their interaction (141). According
to Jameson, in every society there exist different modes of productions that
diachronically and throughout history have been substituted for each other. The
tribal world gave in to the feudal society, which in time was overcome by the
industrial age. Nevertheless, the developing of different systems of production
does not occur in a diachronic or synchronic progression but in a process in which
each economic and social institution exists independently and at the same time
coexists with each other. This heterogeneity can be reflected in texts but also in
the societies portrayed in those texts, as it happens in the case of Memorias.
In the novel, the tribal society in which Balbino's parents are living with all their
traditions clashes with the society of their masters, a still medieval society living
in the countryside, wanting to keep its power and refusing to stop the unjust division
of classes recognized during the industrial age. There is an example of this when
Balbino's father explains to him how he has to respect Manolito in spite of all the
abuse he can impose on Balbino: "'É o neno do señor e abonda'. Pero por
máis que o sexa paréceme que non ten dereito a darme cos seus
zapatiños novos nas canelas, nin cuspirme, nin dicir que, se eles queren,
nós teremos que deixar a casa e as leiras" ["'He is the Master's boy and that
is enough.' But in spite of that I think that he has no right to hit me in the knee
with his new shoes, or to spit on me or to say that if they wanted to we would have
to leave our home and land"] (34).
This coexistence between, on one hand, medieval, industrial, and even more fair and
socialistic societies (represented for instance by the Jew or Balbino's godfather)
and on the other, their experience of progress and history, is a type of "revolution,"
a "cultural revolution" as it is called by Jameson in which development is based on
the grasping of a social formation as a whole, a place where opposing forces live
together and transform such society. "Cultural revolution" permits the preservation
of different ideologemes that allow the transformation of the society: "The triumphant
moment in which a new systemic dominant gains ascendancy is therefore only the
diachronic manifestation of a constant struggle for the perpetuation and reproduction
of its dominance" (97). In Memorias, Galician society is seen as a whole and
growing the seed of a cultural revolution in the sense that the clashing of the
different forces is expected to bring a new balance, a new light in which different
perspectives may come together and respect each other while walking towards the
same end. The fear of the revolution, although stopping the majority of farmers,
is the beginning of enlightenment for Balbino and his godfather.
This vision of society brings about not only what Jameson states as social formations
in which tribal societies and patterns will coexist with the most modern ones, but it
brings the improved performance of the various modes of production. The hope is that
these may become independent and not work against each other. In some ways, this
independence and the freedom to fulfill his own desires is what leads Balbino at
the end of the novel to go away and start a life of his own. In the second to last
chapter, Balbino is going back home when, all of a sudden, he is stopped by Manolito
and his friends who want to beat him up. Balbino knows how the story will end from
his experience other times: Manolito, although a weak coward, will overcome him with
the help of his friends, and Balbino will have to submit to his abuse to keep
everybody happy and safeguard his family's security. However, tired of this type
of life, Balbino fights back and, even mimicking the David and Goliath story,
knocks down Manolito with a stone, leaving him unconscious. He runs away but
his family tracks him down, and in one of the most painful episodes of the story,
his father has to whip him in front of the master, Manolito's father, and pay the
three thousand pesetas to cover Manolito's medical expenses.
Balbino's father tries to find a place for his son where he is not going to be in
trouble, but Balbino takes the lead about his future and decides to leave for the
city instead, finding himself a job where he will not have to be under the mindset
and forces that governed his family and village.2 With this final episode,
the protagonist of the story as well as the text itself breaks with the political
and social ideologemes that were pervading that society and achieves that state of
"nonsynchronous development" and cultural revolution that Jameson encourages. In
the first place, several ideologemes are still in existence. We have already seen
the ones that affected Galician society the most; however, with this last situation
there are new ideologemes. First, there is the episode of the stone, which Balbino
relates as follows: "Anagueime, collín un cantazo e guindeillo con moita forza.
A pedra era coma un paxaro mouro, voando.... Eu botei a correr. Foi coma se espertase
dun pesadelo" ["I bent, I took a stone and I threw it at him with great force. The
stone was like a purplish bird, flying.... I started running. It was like waking
up from a nightmare"] (145). There is a new ideologeme created when Balbino finds
freedom in the act of going against authority. Until this moment, throughout the
novel, the only idea accepted by the society was that of authority; the masters
were the ones dictating rules and types of behavior. Balbino's action, though,
will bring about another idea: that of questioning and resisting abusive authority.
Another type of ideologeme arising from this episode is the idea of individual
freedom and dignity. Balbino never liked the idea that his family submitted to
whatever the master wanted to do, and it is when his father decides to give in
one more time and go to the master's house where he will pay for Manolito's hospital
bill and beat up his own son to give him a lesson in front of the master, when Balbino
finally explodes and spits in the faces of both of them. Finally, another one of the
ideologemes born from this experience is that of independence and personal freedom.
Balbino, tired of his family hopelessness, decides to run away and starts living in
the city on his own. His decision not only reflects that step of a non-synchronous
development in which a society may stop being monosophical and start accepting other
points of view but also initiates the "cultural revolution," where the several modes
of production coexist among them and there is a dissolution of the fear of belonging
to a certain social class.
In Memorias dun neno labrego, as Jameson explained in his work, society and
its modes of production rest on the blind acceptance of the economic systems on the
part of a majority who depend on them and who see their rejection as a sure path to
destruction. Balbino, through his child's eyes, does not see a danger in confronting
the individuals who make this possible, but instead sees danger in keeping silent
and losing life and freedom for trying to survive under the same modes of repression.
Through his eyes, one can confirm that Galicia, as a text, has been written about by
the different social classes as a society where the majority does not have the capacity
to govern, make its own decisions, and succeed. It is always presented as a poor region
where emigration is the only alternative to living under the yoke of the master.
Nevertheless, this ideologeme is challenged by many characters in the novel, the
main one being the protagonist, who sees this state of things as unjust and
nonsensical and who chooses to change it, creating a balance in which the poor
are going to have a voice of their own, if not as a group, at least for themselves.
In spite of his isolation, Balbino's actions at the end are intended to shake the
life of his village although it seems that the changes affect only himself.
Notes
1 Luis Seoane (1910-1979) was one of the most famous Galician painters
of the twentieth century. He was born in Buenos Aires, Argentina, to a family of
Galician immigrants. Very early, he went back to La Coruña, Galicia, with
his family where he furthered his education attending law school in Santiago de
Compostela. In 1932 he became secretary of the Galician Nationalist Party and
started painting illustrations and other works of art for newspapers and also
for other writers such as Alvaro Cunqueiro. In 1936, at the beginning of the
Civil War, he went into exile in Argentina where he founded Galicia Libre
[Free Galicia] (1937), Galicia emigrante [Emigrant Galicia]
(1954) and celebrated his first International exhibition, showing engravings,
oil paintings, and lithographs. It was in this period of the 1950s when Seoane
published his first poetry books: Fardel de eisilado [A Bag of the
Exile] (1952) and Na brétema de Sant-Iago [In Sant-Iago's
Fog] (1956). Vilavedra credits him with the survival of Galician literature
during the dictatorship (Historia 215).
Lorenzo Varela (1916-1978) was born in Cuba although, as it happened with Seoane,
his family returned to Galicia where he studied and became part of Galician
Nationalist Party. In 1936, at the beginning of the war, he was in Madrid and
became a member of the Communist Party, the Alliance of Antifascist Intellectuals
for the Defense of the Culture, and the republican militias. Among his works as a
poet, it is important to point out Lonxe [Far Away] (1954) and
Homaxes [Tributes] (1979). The 2005 Day of Galician Literature
was dedicated to him.
Ramón Suárez Picallo (1894-1964) was a Galician journalist,
politician, and founder of ORGA (Organización Republicana Gallega
Autónoma, or Autonomous Galician Republican Organization) and the
Galician Nationalist Party. He was one of the first representatives of Galicia
in Congress during the II Republic. In his exile, he founded with Castelao
the Consello de Galicia [Galician Counsel] whose main objective was to take
over the government of Galicia in the exile.
Rafael Dieste (1899-1981) is one of the best-known Galician writers in Spanish.
He was part of the Spanish Generation of 27. He entered the world of literature
with the help of another Galician poet and friend Manuel Antonio and very soon
became part of the Seminario de Estudos Galegos [Galician Studies Seminary], an
organization to promote the study and advancement of Galicia and its culture.
During the war he was one of the men in charge of El Mono Azul, manager
of the Teatro Español in Madrid, where he also worked with Rafael Alberti
and Teresa León. During his exile, he was director of Editorial
Atlántida in Buenos Aires, and professor of Spanish Literature at Cambridge
and the Instituto Tecnológico de Monterrey in Mexico. His two best-known
works are Dos arquivos de trasno [From the Archives of the Goblin]
(1926) and A fiestra baldeira [The Empty Window] (1927).
2 At the end of the novel, Balbino makes up his own mind about what to do
once he cannot go back to the village, and he decides to start working for O Landeiro.
Although it may seem that Balbino has fallen again in the traps of the same oppressive
system, Landeiro is considered by him a much more open and enlightened man: "Berra
para falar con un coma se estivese entre cuxos. Pero non é ruin.... Sabe que
se me dá por ler e traime libros" ["He yells to speak as if one was among
calves. But he is not a bad person.... He knows I like reading and he brings me
book"] (154-155).
Works Cited
Alonso Montero, Xesús. "Proemio á vixésima edición."
Memorias dun neno galego. Sada (A Coruña): Ediciós do Castro,
2003. 9-24.
Bloch, Ernst. "Nonsynchronism and Dialectics." New German Critique 11 (1977):
22-38.
Campos Esteve, Carmen. "La presencia de los inmigrantes gallegos en el comercio
de San Juan: 1825-1846." Jornadas de la emigración gallega a Puerto Rico.
Actas del Congreso celebrado en San Juan el 30, 31 de Enero y 1 de febrero de 1996.
Sada (A Coruña): Ediciós do Castro, 1997.
Da Orden, María Liliana. "La inmigración gallega en Mal del Plata:
trabajo, mobilidad y relaciones personales (1895-1930)." La Galicia austral:
la inmigración gallega en la Argentina. Buenos Aires: Editorial Biblos,
2001. 87-106.
Fernández del Riego, Francisco. Manual de historia da literatura
galega. Vigo: Galaxia, 1971.
Jameson, Fredric. The Political Unconscious: Narrative as a Socially
Symbolic Act. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1981.
Hooper, John. The New Spaniards. New York: Penguin, 1995.
Longhini, Nora. Buenos Aires na obra de Neira Vilas. Sada (A Coruña):
Ediciós do Castro, 2003.
Lucas, María. La visión de Galicia en Xosé Neira Vilas.
Sada (A Coruña): Ediciós do Castro, 1977.
Moya, José Carlos. "Los gallegos en Buenos Aires durante el siglo XIX:
Inmigración, adaptación ocupacional e imaginario sexual." La
Galicia austral: la inmigración gallega en la Argentina. Buenos Aires:
Editorial Biblos, 2001. 69-85.
Neira Vilas, Xosé. Memorias dun neno labrego. Sada (A Coruña):
Ediciós do Castro, 2003.
Paz Andrade, Valentín. Castelao na luz e na sombra. Sada
(A Coruña): Ediciós do Castro, 1982.
Rábade Paredes, Xesús. Xosé Neira Vilas e Xente no
rodicio. Vigo: Galaxia, 1992.
Rey Castelao, Ofelia. "Los gallegos en el Río de la Plata durante la
época colonial." La Galicia austral: la inmigración gallega
en la Argentina. Buenos Aires: Editorial Biblos, 2001. 23-51.
Seixas, Xosé Manuel. La Galicia austral: la inmigración gallega
en la Argentina. Buenos Aires: Editorial Biblos, 2001.
Smith, Angel. Historical Dictionary of Spain. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow
Press, 1996.
Son, Corinne. Xosé Neira Vilas y Memorias dun neno labrego:
acercamiento a la novela gallega más popular de la segunda mitad
del siglo XX. Sada (A Coruña): Ediciós do Castro, 2001.
Toro, Xelis de. "Bagpipes and Digital Music: The Remixing of Galician Identity."
Constructing Identity in Contemporary Spain: Theoretical Debates and Cultural
Practice. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003. 237-254.
Tussell, Javier. "Tercera Parte. Época Contemporánea."
Historia de España. Madrid: Grupo Santillana de Ediciones, 2000.
Vázquez, Alejandro. "Factores de empuje y condiciones de transporte de
Galicia hacia el Río de la Plata (1850-1930)." La Galicia austral:
la inmigración gallega en la Argentina. Buenos Aires: Editorial Biblos,
2001. 53-68.
Vilavedra Fernández, Dolores. Historia da literatura galega.
Vigo: Galaxia, 1999.
---. A recepción inmanente na obra de Neira Vilas. Sada
(A Coruña): Ediciós do Castro, 1990.
Ana Carballal is an assistant professor of Spanish literature at the
University of Nebraska-Omaha. Two of her last published articles are
"Vampiros, caníbales y chupadores de sangre: el arte culinario
gallego en la obra de Castelao," and "Spanish Civil War as an Inaugural
Moment in Antonio Buero Vallejo's El tragaluz."
|