Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Margaret Bradham Thornton. Tennessee Williams' Notebooks.
New Haven: Yale University Press, 2006. 765p.
Susan Savage Lee
University of Kentucky
Notebooks, a compilation of Tennessee Williams' personal journals,
photographs, letters, and poetry, intimately illuminates the playwright's
disparaging self-reflections and simultaneous desire for literary success.
Williams metamorphoses from elation to despair, lamenting his father's blatant
disregard for him and his sister's mental deterioration. Amidst the sadness of
his home life, the author always manages to return to it, in particular to his
supportive mother and to "Grand." His natural surroundings, companionships with
other writers, and his eventual success with several critically hailed plays,
serve to boost Williams to hope for more and to question the meaning of life
and his place within it.
Margaret Bradham Thornton, the editor of this volume, spent ten years arranging
Williams' text and letters next to a series of complimentary annotations and
photographs that identify and highlight the playwright's friends and social
circles. Unfortunately, Williams did not always mark notations as to what year
and month the entries were written. Thornton journeyed to archives located in
Texas, Columbia, Yale, and Harvard in order to ascertain the dates of each piece
of writing. Because the playwright voraciously wrote letters to his friends and
acquaintances, Thornton contacted the mentioned persons and scheduled interviews
with them in order to solidify the placement of each entry.
In other instances, the data was difficult to discover; she consequently turned to
extensive databases from companies like Goldman Sachs. Once organized and properly
arranged, Thornton was able to examine the actual content in terms of the precarious
emotional journey Williams suffered for the entirety of his life. She observes that
"The idea that Williams was always waivering on the brink of insanity seemed false
to me." Inspired by the perplexing juxtaposition of Williams' lamentations and his
seemingly stabilized self-presentation, she consulted Paul Bowles and asked his
opinion of the playwright. He explained: "Look at all that he wrote. Tenn knew
exactly what he was doing." The "wretched whining" of Williams as he struggled to
preserve his mental health, according to Thornton, emerges as a form of indulgence
rather than a suicidal tendency.
Thornton's meticulous preparation of Notebooks significantly overshadows
other compilations of authors' journals, memoirs, or personal letters. In comparison
to The Journals of Sylvia Plath, edited by Frances McCullough, and Henry
James's Letters, edited by Leon Edel, for example, Thornton's treatment is far
more thorough, supplying the reader with explanatory notes on the left page that
explain Williams' references on the right page. Because of Thornton's extensive,
detailed list of "clues," the playwright's journals gain greater significance.
In other words, instead of a few footnotes or endnotes that supply the reader
with a referent's identity and significance, Thornton furnishes this type of
information as well as excerpts from interviews with Williams' mentioned friends.
She places photographs of the people at the time Williams knew them next to the
entry, and she arranges Williams' original entries to correspond with his
additional "responses" to them. Each perusal of the pages becomes a moment
where the past comes alive through the playwright's voiced despair over poor
critical reception, lovesickness over "K," and his physical wanderings throughout
the United States and Europe.
The journal captures more than Williams' emotional state, but extends to the
reader the opportunity of peering into his work from the playwright's own
perspective and intent. Before Williams energetically attached himself to
the production of plays, he created short stories that his classes at Washington
University "criticized ... very harshly" and poetry that disappointed him
immensely. Once his plays gained momentum and eventual audience acclaim,
Williams appears to experience reasonably good spirits. Yet his change of
spirit often denotes a transition in his private life in the sense that
he continually strives to obtain quality in his work, hoping that perfection
will ameliorate his disillusionment with himself.
Gaining acknowledgement from his peers, an elusive element in his relationship
with Clark Mills McBurney, proves equally evasive as Williams journeys south
to Key West, losing himself financially because of infrequent recognition and
payment as well as debaucherous evenings with unidentified lovers. Thornton's
summaries between the notebooks illustrates that life imitates art when she
observes that "The audience was offended by the explicit sexuality [in Battle
of Angels] and irritated by the final scene in which smoke billowed out into
the theater" (217). Much like Williams' erotic adventures that he narrates
in his letters to Donald Wildham and others, the playwright did not censure
the content of his plays, offering the audience a brutal depiction of the
down-and-outs, the lonely, and the confused. Notebooks becomes the
development of a man's interior being, his subsequent literary creations,
and his sexuality.
Thornton's painstaking arrangement of Tennessee Williams' Notebooks creates
the sensation that the reader is becoming a part of the past. The evolution of the
photographs of his mother and sister and Williams himself details the passing of a
life in all its finery, brilliance, and artistry. Decades are fleshed out, bringing
alive a world war, along with the literary and acting circles of greats like Gore
Vidal, Marlon Brando, and Jessica Tandy. Her work, an adventurous resurrection of
the past, offers a variety of readers honest and uncensored insight into the making
of an extraordinary artist in twentieth-century America.
|