Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
William W. Kibler and Leslie Zarker Morgan, eds.
Approaches to Teaching the Song of Roland.
NY: The Modern Language Association of America, 2006. 317p. & CD-ROM.
Albrecht Classen
University of Arizona
The Old French Chanson de Roland belongs to the world classics of Western
literature, and it is one of those texts that regularly appear on the reading lists
of undergraduate and graduate classes at North American universities. Under the
competent leadership of the two editors, Kibler and Zarker Morgan, a large number
of North American Romanists have come together to address this fascinating epic
poem both from a philological and a historical and so also from a didactic
and pragmatic point of view. As the series editor emphasizes, all books published
in the series "Approaches to Teaching World Literature" are "intended to serve
nonspecialists as well as specialists, inexperienced as well as experienced
teachers, graduate students ... as well as senior professors" (ix). In order
to gain a solid understanding of the major approaches to Roland in academic
classes in North America, the editors have solicited broad-ranging feedback from all
regions of the United States (and also Canada in one case; plus three contributions
are from British scholars), and the resulting articles make up the present volume.
Despite its Anglophile focus, the discussions and interpretations are of great
value for all scholars and general readers alike interested in this famous Old
French epic.
The volume is divided into two major sections, the first one concerned with
materials, the second with background information and pedagogical approaches.
Philologists will very much welcome the excellent survey of the manuscript
tradition and of the relevant research literature by William W. Kibler, whereas
Leslie Zarker Morgan focuses on modern media through which the text has been
preserved to us, whether in print media or audio-visual media, such as film and
music. The latter is discussed in greater detail by Margaret Switten, who
also explains the content of the accompanying CD-ROM with readings and musical
performances (mostly varying attempts to reconstruct the accompanying music
for the performance of Roland and the music instruments that could
have been used, plus contemporary musical examples).
The articles in the second section concern a wide range of individual topics
relevant for the understanding of Roland and the literary-historical
context, pertaining both to the historical conditions, feudalism, military
history, and technology. Some of the problems rest, of course, in the difference
between the time when the historical events took place (8th century) and when
the epic was composed and written down (early 12th century). Surprisingly,
Barbara Stevenson's interesting study on postcolonial approaches to the Song
of Roland is also included in the first section, whereas it really should
have been placed in a much later section dedicated to this aspect exclusively.
It might have been helpful if Stevenson and Kinoshita, who offers a postcolonial
reading of the text, had been asked to correlate their work, which then would
have allowed the reader to grasp how theoretical perspectives come to bear
in the modern classroom.
The reception of Roland in Italy, Spain, and England was significant,
but so also in Germany, which is mentioned only in passing in two unrelated
articles, whereas the other versions are discussed at length by Jane E. Everson,
Matthew Bailey, and Kimberlee Campbell. Modern reception theory (Medievalism)
plays an important role as well, which finds its reflection in Mark Burde's
article, though he limits himself to the nineteenth century (see, however,
Zarker Morgan's comments on modern cinematographic versions). Students will
particularly welcome the short articles on major characters and episodes,
and so also those offering critical readings. The section on the epic's
text, language, and poetic technique certainly belongs into this volume as
well, but it requires more intellectual acumen to follow the specific
arguments developed here.
At the end, after the notes on the contributors, we find an extensive bibliography
(throughout, there is no critical apparatus!) and a welcome index (not exhaustive,
however). The quality of the readings and the musical performances on the CD-ROM
are of excellent quality and give a very good sense of how hard modern scholars
have to struggle to gain a solid historical understanding of how this epic poem
might have been presented musically to its medieval audiences. Unfortunately,
the description of the various tracks remains somewhat hidden in Margaret
Switten's contribution (36-39).
Undoubtedly, the pragmatic approach to teaching dominates this volume, which is also
its explicit purpose. Nevertheless, many times the contributors obviously enter into
some rather particular debates about their own approach/es without having a chance
to illustrate the complexity of their positions in light of the relevant scholarship.
Nevertheless, the background information, the samples of how to approach this text
in the academic classroom, and the handful of critical readings make this book a
most welcome aid for all those who are in charge of teaching this "classical" medieval
text at the university level.
|