Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Geary Hobson, ed. The Remembered Earth:
An Anthology of Contemporary Native American Literature.
Albuquerque: University of New Mexico Press, 2003. 417p.
RosaMaria Chacon
California State University, Northridge
First published in 1979 (Red Earth Press), the seventh reprinting of The
Remembered Earth by UNM press speaks to its contemporary value and currency.
Part of the value of this anthology is based on the diversity of authors, topics,
and approaches. In alignment with its emphasis on the land and the significance
of land in Native American culture, it is divided, regionally, into four sections
-- Northeast, Southeast, Southwest and Northwest -- and includes authors and
artists from 42 tribes, and 16 states (and Quebec). This diversity is matched
by the genres that the editor chose to incorporate: poetry, drama, short stories,
essays, drawings, photographs, and pieces that defy genre.
In addition to Geary Hobson's coherent delineation of Native American identity
in his introduction and Paula Gunn Allen's portrayal of the primary cultural
characteristics in Native American literature, this anthology can be an asset
in a number of different fields. It would, for example, make an excellent
companion piece in a history course; Luci Tapahonso in "The Snakeman" and
Russell Bates in "Rite of Encounter" address the grim issues of boarding
school and smallpox in a way that demands attention and critical consideration.
Simon J. Ortiz' personal narrative of marching on Gallup, New Mexico in 1973 in
support of the Oglala Sioux struggle at Wounded Knee is both exuberant and somber.
Providing political and historical context from an American Indian perspective,
this piece also examines the generation of modern Indian social activism and
agency. "The story of a People," according to Ortiz, "is the history of what
they are doing" (297).
The thematic diversity of this anthology makes it especially suitable for the
study of early contemporary Native American literature. The authors and artists
address the destruction of the earth, the significance of language and the value
of the stories and songs, ruptures of home and self, and the corollary urgency to
fill these massive gaps, urban places and spaces, and returns and renewals.
Community and continuance are truthfully depicted in Gladys Cardiff's poem
"Combing." She declares, "Preparing hair. Something / Women do for each other,
/ Plaiting the generations" (lines 27-29). Cardiff's declaration is part of the
cultural work of this anthology -- part of the work that moves away from the
concept of the Invented Indian described by Louis Owens in Other Destinies:
Understanding the American Indian Novel. Confounding history and seriously
strenuous efforts, the American Indian has not vanished; nor does he or she
match the other characteristics of the Invented Indian.
The entire text, in fact, definitively positions itself in opposition to this
myth and other malignant historical, social, and cultural myths that surround
American Indians. Claiming their literary, intellectual, and cultural property,
several pieces focus on the pseudo shaman. The authors in this work also provide
a solid context for more contemporary work, thereby adding to its value in the
literature classroom. Almost seeming to anticipate, for example, Gerald Vizenor's
The Trickster of Liberty: Native Heirs to a Wild Baronage and Gordon Henry's
The Light People, Gogisgi / Carroll Arnett satirizes anthropologists in
"Powwow" while Carol Lee Sanchez presents a razor-sharp critique of Native American
museum displays in "(Conversations #1)" -- "SEE THE INDIANS AT THE PUEBLO," she
taunts. The diverse range of pieces that depict anthropocentrically (in Western
terms) rocks chanting and heat dancing foreshadow the work of Thomas King --
his hilarious novel Green Grass, Running Water and his introduction to
the anthology All My Relations, in which he explains the crucial
principle "all my relations."
The most stimulating piece in this anthology is N. Scott Momaday's essay "The Man
Made of Words." Like many of the works in this text, he extends beyond literature
to provide a critical lens for the study of Native American work: literature, art,
culture, and history. He provides a very specific framework for serious consideration
and analysis. Some scholars may erroneously contextualize his ideas in a postmodern
mode. They are, however, expressly particular to his Kiowa life experience. He
writes, "We are what we imagine. Our very existence consists in our imagination of
ourselves. Our best destiny is to imagine, at least, completely, who and what, and
that we are. The greatest tragedy that can befall us is to go unimagined" (167).
One might suggest that the authors and artists in The Remembered Earth have
defied a history of destruction and attempted eradication, and imagined themselves
well. In enjoying their pieces, one needs to attend to the style. The humor and
irony when the speaker suggests in "Buffalo Poem #1" -- for example, that the
"SMALL HERD OF BUFFALO / . . . 'RUNNING WILD' / AT THE ALBUQUERQUE AIRPORT . . .
- - - roam on, brothers . . ." -- are excellent. The only difficulty in using
this text is the lack of titles in the Table of Contents.
In alignment with the cultural reclamation of this text, it is necessary to note that
this review is written from the perspective of an outsider, someone who has studied
Native American literature but is not Native American.
|