Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Mary F. Brewer. Staging Whiteness.
Middletown, CO: Wesleyen University Press, 2005. 236p.
Elisabeth Lofaro
University of South Florida
In Staging Whiteness, Mary Brewer examines the social history and cultural developments
of race in conjunction with British and U.S. theatrical productions in the 20th century,
presenting the theater as a "site of ideological struggle" within which Whiteness has been
constructed and valorized. Her analysis yields that part of the discourse surrounding U.S.
and British theater practices anticipates and enables the White subject. One of Brewer's
goals is to show how Whiteness operates by demonstrating the ways in which race and racism
function both at the institutional level and at the micro-level of the individual. While
the book inevitably touches on Blackness as Other, it focuses on representations of
Whiteness to expose the apparatuses that sustain racism. Each chapter discusses the social
history informing the period under study followed by specific play analyses and shows how
some theatrical productions function against the historical boundaries of race representation
of their cultural milieu while others remain within those parameters. When the theater offered
representations that critiqued White power, it enacted possibilities to resist dominant
ideologies. Furthermore, by showing the myriad White subject positions within 20th-century
British and U.S. theater, Brewer problematizes Whiteness as a "unitary, fixed entity" not
only exposing it as an artifact of multiple discourses but also questioning it as a pure
racial identity. Although British and U.S. cultures differ in historical constructions of
Whiteness and histories, they share the illusion of a constant and consistent White
identity.
Brewer selects both canonical and non-canonical plays based on their focus on Whiteness in
each historical period, concentrating on how they reproduce or challenge dominant myths
regarding the White race and how constructions of Whiteness have changed throughout the 20th
century for various reasons. Furthermore, Brewer connects performance or theatricality to
constructions of race, finding that Whiteness is inherently theatrical. Rather than offering
a grand narrative of Whiteness, however, she traces its historicity to illustrate how the
concept of Whiteness mutated from the turn of the 20th century through the 1990s.
Brewer begins her discussion by historicizing the concept of race. Oppression founded on
racial difference had not always been conceived in terms of skin color; rather, it
initially rested on degrees of moral and cultural refinement, as in the case with British
racism over the Irish already in the Middle Ages, and came to be viewed in terms of skin
color only when British imperialism needed to justify ideologically its enslavement of
Africans. Furthermore, the racialized schema offered a visible representation of difference.
By the mid-19th century, scientific, economic, religious, and political ideologies were all
used to rationalize colonialism despite the inconsistent mythology these contradictory
discourses engendered.
Brewer argues that in addition to dominant discourses, literary and theatrical ideas also
had a powerful effect on popular perception of the racialized subject. From 1900 to 1930
theatrical productions were both influenced by these historical debates and contributed
in generating and conveying an image of what it meant to be a White British national. More
specifically, George Bernard Shaw's Captain Brassbound's Conversion questions
contemporary cultural myths supporting colonial endeavors, exploring options to the
prevailing social order. Similarly, W. Somerset Maugham's The Explorer
interrogates White racial mythology, while simultaneously presenting the virtues
of White colonialism through the epitome of an Edwardian leading character. Nevertheless,
it does not denounce British imperialism; rather, it presents an ambiguous representation
of the colonial project and reaffirms the purportedly natural nexus between Whiteness,
heterosexuality, and power by positing homosocial bonds as superior even to heterosexual
ones. W. H. Auden and Christopher Isherwood's The Ascent of F6 also illustrates
the ways in which Whiteness retains its cultural authority despite its essential
inconsistencies.
The investigation continues by tracing the evolution of the prevailing notions of
racial difference through British colonial discourse, showing how constructions of
Whiteness operate in terms of the colonial myth of Manifest Destiny. Upon contact with
American soil, White settlers considered themselves superior to the natives in terms of
social practices -- White English capitalist "forms" centered upon private ownership of
commodities and enclosed land as opposed to the natives' communal ways and tribal
spiritual practices -- rather than physical characteristics. When great numbers of
indentured servants had earned release, however, the land-owning gentry, feeling
threatened by the possibility of White and Black laborers joining forces, advanced
race-consciousness over class-consciousness. The mere possibility that non-Whites
could come to resemble White Europeans threatened the British sense of superiority,
and by the late Victorian era, competing types of Whiteness and Otherness appeared
and circulated. As a result, Blackness became tantamount with the subhuman. Although
the concept of "variegated Whiteness" emerged to account for the great numbers of
non-English speaking immigrants, White ethnicities could be a part of Whiteness
eventually, while Blacks remained firmly secured at the bottom of the U.S. socio-racial
hierarchy. Naturally inferior non-White ethnic groups, according to this view, could
better themselves by approximating Whiteness. Brewer examines Eugene O'Neill's
The Hairy Ape, which challenges the myth of the American Dream even for White
people; Langston Hughes' Mulatto, which explores cross-racial sexual relations;
Thornton Wilder's Our Town, which demonstrates the nexus between sex-gender
subordination, racial oppression, and class domination; and Lillian Hellman's
The Little Foxes, which exemplifies how myth functions to smooth over
contradictions within social relations.
The effect of WWII altered the social context of race in both the Britain and the United States.
By the end of the war, the British Empire began its decline. With the crumbling of the British
Empire, great numbers of formerly colonized people immigrated to Britain. While colonial
subjects were welcome as members of the war effort, when the war ended, they were felt as
rivals for jobs that the British felt belonged to them. As Britain struggled to create a
new, postwar identity, Whiteness became the unifying symbol of Britishness, and British
society began to mirror U.S. racist practices. Bridget Boland's The Cockpit reflected
these practices, making an appeal for racial tolerance. T.S. Eliot's The Cocktail Party
also explored but did not resolve classical colonial tensions, while John Osborne's
The Entertainer displayed how racial fictions create modern British identity.
In the U.S., for the first time in history, the willing involvement of Blacks was crucial
for victory, both at home and in the armed forces, yet Blacks still did not gain entrance
as first-class citizens. Further, after the war, anxieties over the future of White dominance
emerged, as enemies of the American-way-of-life also became an issue, blending anticommunist
dogma with racial politics during the '50s. Any attempt at reform was deemed un-American.
Brewer looks at Eugene O'Neill's The Iceman Cometh, Tennessee Williams' A Streetcar
Named Desire, and Arthur Miller's A View From the Bridge in this section.
Next, Brewer explores the 1960s, as the U.S. economy continued to flourish and the conditions
of education, technology, culture, and leisure improved considerably -- for White Americans.
The Civil Rights movement and anti-Vietnam war sentiment contributed to the realization
that the U.S. was not as invincible as was once thought, and the confidence in the moral
exclusivity and manifest destiny also eroded. Brewer looks at Edward Albee's The
American Dream, Amiri Baraka's Dutchman, and David Rabe's Sticks and Bones
in terms how they interrogate Whiteness and look at the underbelly of the American way
of life. Further, she looks at the feminist movement, which, while also attacking White
male hegemony, was in many ways complicit with it. Adrienne Kennedy's A Movie Star
Has to Star in Black and White reveals how the Whiteness begins to fracture as the
race-gender binaries come undone.
The last two chapters of the book look at the rise of neoconservative discourse in the 1980s
and the accompanying White backlash. Women and homosexuals joined Blacks as scapegoats, as
the dominant group sought to contain them while attempting to resolve the crisis in White
masculinity. Nevertheless, both in the U.S. and in Britain, even though Whiteness came
under scrutiny, Blacks remained at the bottom sprung of society, relegated to the lowest
paying jobs regardless of education and skills. Brewer concludes by discussing John
Arden and Margaretta D'Arcy's The Island of the Mighty, Caryl Churchill's Cloud
Nine, Wendy Wasserstein's The Heidi Chronicles, Tony Kushner's Angels in
America, Suzan-Lori Parks' The America Play, Philip Osment's This Island's
Mine, and Michael Ellis' Chameleon.
Staging Whiteness is not only for teachers and students of 20th-century British and
American Drama but also for anyone interested in Whiteness and Critical Race Studies. Its
major strengths are its remarkable tracing of U.S. and British history, lucid use of critical
race theory, attention to the multiple discourses that complicate Whiteness, and cogent
analyses of theatrical productions. Brewer reveals Whiteness as the historical product
of social and economic competition, a fragmented myth, and ultimately an illusion.
|