Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Carolyn A. Durham. Literary Globalism:
Anglo-American Fiction Set in France.
Lewisburg: Bucknell University Presses, 2005. 265p.
Helynne H. Hansen
Western State College of Colorado
This collection of essays by Carolyn A. Durham takes a major step in demystifying the
ever-growing fascination with France in English-language literature that goes back at
least as far as 1841 when Edgar Allan Poe (who never traveled to France but loved the
works of Balzac and Hugo) published "The Murders on the Rue Morgue."
Durham notes that the thriving Anglo-American passion for everything French was magnified
in the 1920s and 1930s when Ernest Hemingway, Gertrude Stein, and other writers of the
"Lost Generation" migrated to the Bohemian quartiers of Paris to drink, commiserate,
and create. In 1919, Shakespeare and Company, an English-language bookstore, was
established in Paris' 5ème arrondissement, and has since expanded to include a
library, salon and neighborhood clubhouse. In her Introduction, Durham reports that the
bookstore held its first literary festival in 2003 to observe and honor French influence
on English-language literature. In recent years, several competing Anglophone bookstores
have cropped up in Paris as well.
Durham's colorful historical overview of English-language writers' interest in French
culture is an interesting backdrop to her primary focus on the surge during the past
twenty years of Anglophone novels that take place in France and involve the interaction
of English, American, and French characters. In her first chapter, the author quotes a
French bride-to-be, Anne-Sophie, in Diane Johnson's Le Mariage (2000), who surveys
a gathering of Americans in Paris. "Was this a reception for ... someone what had written
a book, another book, about France? Zut, they produced them endlessly, Anglophones
and their books" (Durham 25).
These nine essays are broadly researched and footnoted, and conclude with an extensive
bibliography attesting to Durham's knowledge of other recent studies about the ongoing
prickly relationship between the United States and France -- and there are many such
works. Among the titles from which she quotes are Paris in American Literature by
Jean Méral (1989), Imagining Paris: Exile, Writing, and American Identity,
by J. Gerald Kennedy (1993), Seducing the French: The Dilemma of Americanization
by Richard F. Kuisel (1993), and French Resistance: The French-American Culture Wars,
by Jean-Philippe Mathy (2000).
A quick caveat to Internet book-buying junkies like myself: as many of the novels Durham
analyzes are quite recent and have not yet found their way into every campus and public
library, these essays with all of their intriguing descriptions and comments may well
send you on a spending spree.
The Anglophone novels by Johnson, Rose Tremain, Joanne Harris, Claire Messud, Edmund White,
and others not only have sold well in France in their original English versions, but also
have been translated into French with unusual rapidity, Durham reports. "At the same time,
however, English is fast becoming the international language of a culturally unified
Europe" (23).
One of Durham's major emphases is how these various authors use certain postmodernist
writing strategies to suggest creeping globalization of cultures as they affect France,
England, and the United States. Postmodernism, is, in fact, the literary counterpart of
globalization, she states (27); "in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries
even mainstream English-language fiction can no longer be contained within conventional
boundaries whether narrative, national, or even perhaps, linguistic. In an increasingly
globalized world of constant border crossing and cultural borrowing, notions of national
origin and native language no longer retain the same meaning" (23).
Durham's first chapter examines Johnson's Le Divorce (1997), upon which the
popular 2003 Hollywood film was based, and Le Mariage (2000), both of which examine
a series of cross-cultural (mostly Franco-American) romances with various troubled dynamics.
In fatal Racinian tradition, every relationship in these novels is unsuitable in one way
or another, and thereby, doomed. "Selecting elements indiscriminately from American and
European culture, Le Divorce and Le Mariage recombine and rearrange them
in a fashion ... that is distinctively postmodern" (40).
Durham opts to examine Johnson's third novel L'Affaire (2003) in her ninth and
last chapter, and to point out through the story's good-hearted, but bumbling, American
heroine Amy, that anti-U.S. sentiment among the French is simply inevitable and even
formulaic in these kinds of novels. Amy's innocent acts of ill-advised good will
(which include whisking an avalanche victim from the Alps to a London hospital, where
he dies) are a microcosm of many recent well-intentioned, but disastrous, U.S. military
tactics (201).
The fact that Johnson's title L'Affaire is a word that has many meanings in French
besides the assumed English interpretation of adultery, reiterates the surety of
ever-present ambiguities in writings that cross borders and cultures that haunt every
Anglophone novel set in France, Durham opines in her last chapter.
Chapter 2 discusses Tremain's The Way I Found Her wherein Lewis, a 13-year-old
English boy spending a summer in Paris with his translator-mother, becomes fascinated
with the novel Le Grand Meaulnes, and attempts to translate it into English on
his own. Tremain assumes all her readers are familiar with Alain-Fournier's 1913
masterpiece, thereby suggesting a sort of cultural globalism (45). "One of Tremain's
essential insights about the future of culture in a globalized Europe is that literature
can become international in reach without losing the national specificity of its
origins" (56).
Tremain's readers see various dilemmas Lewis has with language as he translates. His
variety of words choices suggest the experimentalism of Robbe-Grillet, and he poses
some interesting questions about translators and how much liberty they do or do not
have. Tremain also revives the adage that translation is always a form of betrayal
as well as an act of creativity ... a kind of plagiarism in reverse, portraying one's
own language as someone else's. "More importantly, in an increasingly globalized world
of border crossings and constant cultural borrowing, can notions of national origin and
native language still retain either meaning or significance?" Duraham asks (59).
She speculates that reason behind the growing number of Anglophone novels about France
since the early 1990s is elusive, but might by due in part to the "Peter Mayer effect":
that is, the success of the English author's best-selling books -- A Year in Provence
(1990; the source of a 1993 TV mini-series as well as a looser adaptation in the 2006 film
A Good Year starring Russell Crowe), and Toujours Provence (1991) about his
own experiences buying an estate in southern France, and the resultant culture clashes,
as well as his fictional Hotel Pastis: A Novel of Provence (1993). Chapters 4 and 5
treat this yearning of Anglophones for the disappearing charm of bucolic small towns in
France as described in Harris' Chocolat (1999; also the source of a successful
Hollywood film), and Blackberry Wine (2000).
One of Durham's most intriguing chapters is her analysis of Massud's The Last Life,
a novel originally written in English, but whose characters are, for the most part, speaking
in French. The Last Life -- or, in its ironically inexact French translation, La
Vie Après -- is a Bildungsroman narrated in first person by bilingual Sagesse
LaBasse who recounts her life as a teen living with her American mother and French-Algerian
father in southern France. A psychological study of troubled characters unable to adjust
to the loss of French colonialism, The Last Life concludes with Sagesse's realization
of Camus' philosophy that despite her family members who remain mired in other people's
expectations and rules, she has freedom to chart her own course -- which she eventually
does as an expatriate herself in New York City.
Fans of the myriads of murder mysteries set in Paris over the centuries will enjoy
Chapters 6 and 7, in which Durham examines recent Anglophone romans policiers such
as Mascarade by Walter Satterthwait (1998), Murder in Montparnasse by Howard
Engles (1999) and Murder in the Latin Quarter by Tony Hays (1993) as well as Sarah
Smith's historical detective novels, such as The Knowledge of Water (1996), which
takes place in 1910 Paris, and recalls the Gertrude Stein era of museum-like setting and
period salons.
Chapter 8 treats another significant subcategory of Anglophone novels set in France --
those that feature homosexual protagonists. Durham quotes Edmund White's claim that ever
since Henry James, American writers have wanted to describe the experience of a relationship
between "a very open American and a very enigmatic Frenchman" (177). Her analysis of
White's The Married Man (2000) calls this work a "comedy of manners" in the
tradition of James as well as a love story, a portrait of Paris, a social satire, a
cross-cultural comparison, an AIDS chronicle, a semi-autobiographical portrait of
White, a psychological mystery, and a travelogue (165-166).
At the end of her chapters, Durham includes a substantial list for further reading
of other Anglophone novels about English or American characters that are set in France
and have appeared between 1994 and 2004.
|