Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Maximillian E. Novak and Carl Fisher, eds.
Approaches to Teaching Defoe's Robinson Crusoe.
NY: Modern Language Association of America, 2005. 243p.
Nina Chordas
University of Alaska Southeast, Juneau
As a story, Daniel Defoe's Robinson Crusoe struck a cultural nerve upon its
publication in 1719 that still resonates today: as many contributors to this collection
point out, students tend to be familiar with the central figure of the castaway on a desert
island, attempting to construct himself and his world anew. When they encounter it in
college, however, the novel itself often seems remote, a perception exacerbated by its
18th-century diction and pacing. The challenge for the teacher seeking to present
Crusoe in the classroom is therefore laid out. In their Introduction to this
volume, the editors promise that the essays included in it "address how to make
Robinson Crusoe a living text and not merely a document of the past" (xii). As a
college professor about to teach Crusoe for the first time in a survey course, I
took their words to heart and read the contents with the double purpose of reviewing
them for this publication and gaining some insights into presenting Defoe's novel
to undergraduates.
I will say up front that I was not disappointed. Both the content and apparatus of this
recent addition to the MLA Approaches to Teaching series are helpful and informative
for the would-be teacher of Defoe's groundbreaking text. The cumulative effect of the essays
collected here is to show not only that Crusoe indeed broke new ground when it
appeared but in what ways this was, and continues to be, so. The volume is divided into
two sections titled "Materials" and "Approaches." In addition to items such as an overview
of the novel's publishing history and a brief biography of Defoe, the "Materials" section
situates Crusoe in an international context, one established almost immediately upon
its publication as the novel was translated and adapted in various languages, giving rise
to a genre called the Robinsonade. The international context sketched out in the
"Materials" section is reinforced by many of the essays that appear under "Approaches";
for example, Carl Fisher's "The Robinsonade: The Cultural History of an Idea" (129-139)
discusses the thematic approaches of British, French, and German works appropriating
elements of Crusoe, including modern Robinsonades and bibliographies, while Charles
W. Pollard looks at modern takes on Defoe's novel in "Teaching Contemporary Responses
to Robinson Crusoe: Coetzee, Walcott, and Others in a World Literature Survey"
(161-168). Other essays, even some of those not specifically concerned with international
contexts, nevertheless treat the topic in the course of their own discussions. Indeed,
this complementarity between the two sections is characteristic of the entire volume,
and is one of the factors that make it so satisfying for the reader who is attempting
both to get a critical/historical handle on Defoe's text and to gather some ideas about
teaching it. The lengthy discussion of Crusoe in its generic context in "Materials"
also finds echoes in various essays in "Approaches."
The Introduction does an excellent job, as good Introductions should, of adumbrating many of
the social and cultural issues addressed in the collected essays as well. Robinson Crusoe
is a rich text, speaking both historically and thematically, for managing to raise questions
about broad issues such as race, gender, class, materiality, economics, and self-construction,
among others. The "Approaches" section is consequently divided into subsections whose
titles indicate the range of topics under consideration here: "Defoe and the History of
English Narrative," "Intellectual and Ideological Contexts," "Formal and Thematic Approaches,"
"Comparative and Intertextual Approaches," and "Classroom Contexts for Robinson Crusoe."
Gender issues are treated in essays as disparate as George E. Haggerty's "Thank God It's
Friday: The Construction of Masculinity in Robinson Crusoe" (in the "Intellectual and
Ideological Contexts" subsection, 78-87) and Laura M. Stevens' "Reading the Hermit's
Manuscript: The Female American and Female Robinsonades" (in the "Comparative and
Intertextual Approaches" subsection, 140-151). The interspersion of themes and issues
among the subsections helps make this a volume perhaps best read holistically, though
each subsection can also stand on its own.
Nearly every essay in this volume discusses Crusoe in relation to other works,
including travel narratives, parodies, female Robinsonades, other 18th-century texts,
philosophical treatises, literary criticism, and film. This intertextuality is particularly
helpful in providing insights into the many various contexts in which Crusoe may be
profitably studied. Suggested clusterings of Crusoe with other texts additionally
provide pedagogical approaches for the would-be teacher of this novel. The subsection on
classroom contexts contains essays concerning the inclusion of Crusoe in specific
courses such as the survey, or even in a business school. Neither is children's
literature neglected, since the figure of Crusoe has many descendants in that field.
Space does not permit the listing and discussion of every contribution to this collection,
but without exception they provide useful insights into the presentation of Defoe's novel
to students. Reading through the essays gives one a strong sense of Defoe's time and the
ways in which we can show, through his novel, how its concerns live on in our own. This
is a volume that admirably succeeds in fulfilling its stated purpose.
|