Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Marie-Christine Koop and Rosalie Vermette, eds.
La France à l'aube du XXIe siècle: Tendances et mutations.
[France at the Dawn of the Twenty-First Century: Trends and Transformations.]
Birmingham, AL: Summa, 2000. 286p.
Kathryn Eberle Wildgen
University of New Orleans
This ambitious project involved nineteen authors, each
contributing one essay on a variety of topics as outlined in the title of the
book: the political, social, and cultural aspects of France at the turn of the
century. The last section is devoted to American perceptions of France, a
reading that should be complemented by Serge Abrate's two-part study of
Franco-American relations in the American Association of Teachers of French
National Bulletin 30.2 (November 2004) and
30.3 (January 2005). Abrate, of course, has the advantage of seeing these
relations from the post-Iraq War perspective whereas the essays included in
Koop's book were composed pre-2000. In a sense, because of the time required to
find a publisher and get a manuscript into print, every scholarly book is
obsolete when it hits bookshelves. Through no fault of the authors involved,
this is especially true of this work. Koop's effort may have been more
interesting had it been done after the meltdown in Franco-American relations,
but every work must be taken in the context of its composition and judged on
its own merits, not on the basis of "what-if"s.
The contents of the book were finalized in 1997 at a
time well before the Iraq War, the catastrophic heat wave that caused a
scandalous death rate among France's elderly population, allegations of French
involvement in the United Nations oil-for-food program, drastic revisions in
France's employment and social security programs, and other events that brought
about seismic changes in precisely those aspects of French society discussed in
this book. Perhaps it is just that fact that will make this book of such
interest and value to those future scholars who wish to examine the effects of
George W. Bush's presidency and of the 2004 election on America's European
policies and relations. It offers a thumbnail sketch of what was just before
what is. A striking conclusion one may draw from this study is how similar in
nature and in scope are France's situations and problems to those of the U.S.: an
aging population in need of an overhaul in health care and social security; the
family and how to place gay couples in that context; inequalities among
educational degrees, among others.
I caution that this book is not for novices, those
utterly unaware of how France works as a political entity. Most authors offer
valuable navigation through the alphabet soup (RPR, UDF, SMIC...) of French
political shorthand. However, it is at times difficult to discern the audience
for whom this work was intended. It is arguable that if one understands the
arguments made in the essays, particularly those concerning politics, one has
no need to read them. It is also the case that the essays are of uneven
quality; however, their interest will lie, of course, in the eye of the reader.
This is essentially a book of facts and statistics, with very little
interpretation or "value judgments." (A notable exception to this
generalized critique are the chapters on graffiti and social issues, and on
France "in trouble or just in transition.") There is a signal lack of
attention given to the place of the church or to religious/moral values in
France; a brief overview of the convulsions of church-state relations
throughout the ages would have been a useful introduction to this missing element.
Even the most ardent anti-clerical Frenchman will agree that the church placed
its stamp on the development of the nation and remains a solid part of France's
patrimoine. Missing as well is
discussion of anti-Semitism and of anti-Muslim sentiment in the context of this
patrimoine. I emphasize that it
is "in this context" because several of the chapters focus more on
the situation of Arabs in France than on France itself. An overriding theme of
this book seems to be the sense of loss of French identity on the part of the
French themselves. This sentiment springs from a perceived physical invasion by
foreigners and a suspected cultural invasion by Americans, especially involving
the replacement of French by English on the world stage.
It is a practical impossibility to give each essay
the attention it deserves, so I will concentrate on each section with a brief
mention of selected authors. The longest section of France at the Dawn...
is the first of five: politics. As in four of the
five sections, at least one essay is in French, to be expected from a Summa
publication, a house specializing in French studies. Douglas J. Daniels offers
a good explanation of "cohabitation" and of the fact that it is
virtually built into the French governmental paradigm. Those who have had the
misfortune of breathing Parisian air will be relieved to know that the French
are at last taking environmental issues seriously. However, the perception that
pro-environmental positions are against the interests of developing nations and
France's commitment to "nuclearization" hamper a thorough
"greening" of the country as does the firm belief that the obsession
with second-hand smoke is an "American obsession" and therefore
suspect. (I have known vociferous anti-nuclear "Greens" who smoke!)
The chapter, "France's Aging Population," projects into the year 2005
and one may compare Alice Strange's prescient discussion of this
"watershed year" with current national arguments by reading any of
the on-line French newspapers, especially Le Monde (www.lemonde.fr). Of especial
interest is France's
consideration of exactly the same "fixes" for a social security
system in allegedly imminent crisis as those proposed by the current U.S.
administration, including personal retirement accounts (plans d'épargne
retraite). The three chapters on French
"identity" demonstrate to an extraordinary degree how similar are
France's and America's struggles with diversity and multiculturalism. The
section on cultural issues describes what the French have at their disposal to
fill their (considerable) leisure time: novels whose main focus is on
contemporary social issues (read: immigration and assimilation); French films;
and "cultural spaces," especially the "metal and glass"
ones which replaced or severely reconfigured the revered Louvre, the BNF, and
Les Halles. The extremely interesting chapter on French film by Jeri DeBois
King cites Dudley Andrew's interesting assertion that the French cinema is not
a cultural artifact, but rather a propaganda tool rendering creativity
impossible (208). The hottest topic of the book, Franco-American relations, is
left for last. The editor of France at the Dawn... wisely selected a Frenchman,
Michel Sage, writing in
French, to approach the delicate topic of relations between France and the USA.
Sage's position, that America regards France (usually) as a military ally but a
cultural enemy, is particularly astute. The Conclusion provides a useful
compendium of recent titles for further reading on the topics discussed in this
book. Brief biographies of the book's contributing authors close the text.
There is no index.
In terms of form, the book should have undergone some serious proofreading. There are,
scattered throughout, inexplicable (and distracting) gaps between words, and some
incidences of careless composition and/or typos: "help" in place of
"helped" (18); "This has not and will not happen" (25);
"chaffing about" when "chafing against" is meant (47); the use
of "disinterested" when "uninterested" would be preferable, and the misidentification
of the film Cousin, Cousine as Cousins, Cousines (260).
|