Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Marcia McClintock Folsom, ed. Approaches to Teaching Austen's Emma.
New York: The Modern Language Association of America, 2004. 200p.
Kandi Tayebi
Sam Houston State University
The 1990s showed a dramatic increase of interest in Austen's novel Emma, including
the immense popularity of three movies
based on the book: Amy Heckerling's Clueless, Douglas McGrath's Emma,
and Diarmuid Lawrence's Emma.
These films have led young readers to Emma
for the first time and encouraged teachers to place Emma
on their reading lists for courses ranging from
18th- or 19th-century novel courses to classes on women writers. According to
Joseph Gibaldi, the series editor, MLA's thoughtful series Approaches
to Teaching World Literature attempts to
"collect within each volume different points of view on teaching a
specific literary work, a literary tradition, or a writer widely taught at the
undergraduate level" (ix). The volume includes a section on materials,
succinctly delineated by Folsom, although perhaps too many works are not
included, and a set of essays discussing approaches to teaching the novel. This
volume amply meets the aims of the series, resulting in a teaching guide that
provides an overview of the approaches currently available.
The
essays are grouped in five sections: Social and Political Contexts; Literary
Contexts; Teaching about Class and Gender in Emma; Teaching about Language in
Emma; Teaching Specific Scenes, Patterns, or Words in Emma.
As these headings suggest, the essays are intended
to provide the reader with critical perspectives such as feminism, Marxism, and
post-colonialism, as well as close readings of passages focusing on Austen's
literary style, word choice, and narrative technique. The scope of approaches
covered in the essays is impressive, if not, by necessity, comprehensive.
Emma, as several contributors to the volume note, poses
unique problems for the teacher in an undergraduate class because it appears as
if "nothing happens" (xviii). The historical significance or moral
conflict of the usual novel is missing for Emma. Overcoming these problems is
essential to teaching
the work, and several essays help teachers find processes to explore the
complexities of Austen's novel. Julia Prewitt Brown's essay, "The Everyday
of Emma," explores Austen as
a talented and cutting-edge author who describes the relationship between
everyday life and the value of an individual's life. In a time when most
students are trained to study literary works focused on the historical
significance of the story, Emma can frustrate the student of history. Brown's
essay explains Austen's choice to
write not of political and historical concerns but of the realities and
importance of our everyday lives.
Several
essays, such as Dorice Williams Elliott's "Teaching about Free Indirect
Discourse" and John Wiltshire's "Health, Comfort, and Creativity: A
Reading of Emma," provide close
reading of passages that reveal the intricate world of language Austen has
woven. Miss Bates and the Box Hill episode are both analyzed closely in Jonathan
H. Grossman's "Manners in Emma"
and Pamela S. Bromberg's "Learning to Listen: Teaching about the Talk of
Miss Bates." Discovering patterns and exploring the reader's process,
these essays help the reader pay attention to what at first appears to be the
characters' unimportant and inconsequential discussions. Grossman's essay
examines the power relationship inherent in manners and gossip, and thus these
close readings provide the teacher with good jumping-off points for encouraging
discussion of Emma on a deeper
level.
Perhaps
the most comprehensive essays in the collection discuss feminist approaches to
Austen's Emma. Devoney Looser's essay on
18th-century feminism and female patronage provides valuable information while
tracing the ideas of feminism from the 18th century to the current time.
Placing Emma in the female novel
tradition, Lorna Clark extends our understanding of Austen's place in the
literary canon. Clark succeeds in placing Austen's "innovations,
discoveries, and achievements in better perspective" by reminding readers
that she wrote "within a rich cultural and literary context" (54).
Each of the feminist essays concludes that Austen critiques her society's view
of women and their roles. Some, like Patricia Howell Michaelson's
"Language and Gender in Emma,"
encourage teachers to examine "the norms of language and gender that had
developed in [Austen's] time" (134) and that remain with us today.
Although necessarily short, her essay provides another powerful example of the
use of close readings.
Perhaps
the most important essay in the collection is Ruth Perry's "Jane Austen,
Slavery, and British Imperialism." Edward Said in his famous essay
"Jane Austen and Empire" denounces Austen as complicit in the
imperialistic ambitions of Britain. Perry's essay answers Said by showing that
Austen's views on slavery connect all exploited humans and thus comment not
only on the exploitation occurring outside Britain but also inside its borders
toward other races and women as well.
Overall, anyone who has attempted to teach Emma on the undergraduate level
will find much in this collection to inspire new approaches. Since Austen's works are
already widely read by students, many students will bring preconceived ideas about
Emma to the classroom. This volume helps teachers find ways to question these
assumptions.
|