Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Hunt Hawkins and Brian W. Shaffer, eds.
Approaches to Teaching Conrad's Heart of Darkness and The Secret Sharer.
New York: MLA, 2002. 195p.
Cathia Jenainati
The University of Warwick
Heart of Darkness is a convoluted and polyphonic postcolonial parable. It is also a
controversial narrative in which Conrad's blatantly racist discourse overshadows many of its
literary qualities. In fact Heart of Darkness still causes a great deal of controversy for
its use of the word "nigger" and until recently it was banned -- along with Conrad's other
controversial novella The Nigger of the "Narcissus" -- in many American high schools
and colleges. Although many critics agree that there is little doubt that Conrad would
have been aware in 1898 that the word "nigger" was derogatory, yet an astute critic and
educator must be able to overcome the limitations of language and ponder the implications
of both genre and characterization in order to attain a confident level of understanding
of the complexity of Conrad's tales. For beyond the problematic issue of race lie crucial
questions about the consequences of imperialism and empire building, the essence of evil,
gender politics, and madness. Hence the educator, like the literary critic, must be able to
differentiate between Conrad the writer and his creation, the racist narrator Marlow.
When I came across Hawkins and Shaffer's edited collection of essays I had particular
expectations I was hoping for this book to fulfill. I was particularly interested in
reading about strategies that various educators have devised to tackle the questions
of race, class, and gender. I was curious about the extent to which the historical
context is being taught and whether some instructors engage with other media in teaching
Conrad's fiction. Finally, as I teach Heart of Darkness on a Critical Practice module,
I was particularly interested in other instructors' experiences of including Conrad in
theory courses.
Hawkins and Shaffer have managed to put together a collection of useful essays detailing
practical and often original approaches to teaching both Heart of Darkness and
The Secret Sharer. In particular, John A. McClure, Carola Kaplan, and Philip M.
Weinstein's essays stand out as examples of perceptive reflections on the novels. McClure's
essay, as its title implies, engages with "Colonial and Postcolonial Contexts for Teaching
'Heart of Darkness.'" His approach to the text involves a critical reading of Conrad's
narrative in relation to Said and Achebe's criticism of it as a racist text. McClure's
strategy involves a two-fold cognitive process by which students are initially
encouraged to think along the lines of Said and Achebe's condemnation of imperial
discourse in the novel and to research its historical background for evidence in
support of the latter criticism. Subsequently, McClure invites his audience to conduct
close textual analyses and to identify the particular instances where "the discourse of
imperialism, with its proclamations of cultural and racial superiority, its exoticizing
of colonial others, and its celebration of European expansion as a civilizing mission
[is] most dramatically deployed" (43). This approach provides students with an opportunity
to unearth the latent irony in Conrad's narrative strategy all the while highlighting the
importance of conducting critical analyses from a variety of perspectives. McClure's
laudable pedagogical philosophy is elucidated in his statement of the rationale for
his approach as one that seeks to "honor postcolonial readings of the text and to revise
these readings in a manner consistent with the values of postcolonial criticism" (46).
Both Kaplan's and Weinstein's approaches follow a similar pedagogical pattern whereby
students are alerted and encouraged to engage with the various discourses employed in
the narrative. In her approach to teaching Heart of Darkness and The Secret Sharer,
Kaplan emphasizes the implications of genre (modernism) in her reading of gender issues.
Deconstruction and psychoanalysis provide useful theoretical tools for students attempting
to grasp the representation of the "feminine within the sous rature of modernism" (101).
But perhaps the most interesting aspect of her approach is its culmination in an
exercise of freewriting which demands of students a creative and emotive response
to Conrad's use of language in the opening scene of Heart of Darkness. Weinstein
however, outlines a pedagogical approach which aims to contextualize Conrad's writing
within a tradition of modern and post-modern narratives, and reads it as belonging to a
canon of texts by such authors as Achebe, Cracià-Márquez, Morrison, Silko,
Erdrich, and Rushdie. His approach can be useful -- though his essay does not provide
practical descriptions of his strategies -- in alerting instructors to possible
comparative texts.
Many other instances of original and practical strategies are outlined in this edition.
One of the strengths of the editors' choice of essays lies in the variety of critical
perspectives adopted by the contributors. For whilst some approaches such as Stevens,
Militello, Eaton, and Norris highlight the importance of the historical context,
others such as White, Williams, Fleisham, and Richardson alert students to elements of
the narratology, including themes, characterization, audience, and cultural setting.
In addition, this collection of essays is particularly useful in presenting a case
for teaching Conrad outside literary studies in fields such as creative writing, film
studies, and, surprisingly, at a Naval Academy.
But perhaps the most outstanding feature of this collection is the editor's own introductory
section, "Materials," in which Hawkins manages to achieve three challenging tasks: he
thoroughly outlines the abundant scholarship on each of Conrad's texts; next he
critically assesses major essays and background works; and finally he meticulously
cites and reviews the various audiovisual aids related to Conrad's fiction. This clear
and concise chapter will provide instructors with a reliable and comprehensive set of
references to any form of scholarship on Conrad. Hawkins' introductory section paves
the ways for essays in the collection and will no doubt prove invaluable for instructors.
|