Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Paul Maurice Clogan, ed. Medievalia et Humanistica.
Studies in Medieval and Renaissance Culture. New Series #30:
Humanist Educational Theory, Gregory the Great, and Culinary Comedy
Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 2004. 165p.
Albrecht Classen
University of Arizona
This journal has been in existence since 1943 and was, according to the jacket, "the first
scholarly publication in America to devote itself entirely to medieval and
Renaissance studies." The present volume contains seven articles, two
review articles, and twelve book reviews. The thematic orientation ranges from
the early Middle Ages to the Renaissance, and the authors focus on English,
Italian, Latin, French, and Hungarian material. There is no apparent
chronological or thematic order of the articles despite the volume's subtitle;
instead, Jane Griffiths begins with an analysis of Skelton's bizarre and
difficult to interpret poem "Speke Parot" from 1521, followed by
Sarah Gordon's investigation of culinary comedy in French Arthurian romance,
then by studies on Hungarian law, pilgrimage accounts, and equipment for
monastic foundations. Most articles have about the same length, but their
scholarly apparatus differs in format, though the Chicago style dominates. Mediaevalia
et Humanistica has obviously achieved an
international reputation judging on the basis of the nationality of the various
authors. As a slight oddity, contrary to normal standards, even two fairly
short articles by John R.C. Martyn, University of Melbourne, are included. Jane
Griffith holds a chair at St. Edmund Hall, Oxford; Fabian Alfie teaches at the
University of Arizona (not Arizona State University, as indicated in the Table
of Contents); Sarah Gordon is employed at the Utah State University, Joseph
Grossi Jr. teaches at Canisius College, and Z.J. Kosztolnyik at Texas A&M
University. The editor offers brief summaries of the individual contributions,
giving special accolades to Joseph Grossi Jr.'s research, but the other
articles are no less worthy of praise for their scholarship. The range of
themes and issues covered by the books reviewed here is wide and offers a nice
variety for many medievalists. I myself find it deplorable, however, that many
language areas in Medieval Studies are not represented in this volume, such as
German, Scandinavian, Spanish, Slavic, and Celtic.
Jane Griffiths argues that there is considerably more meaning to John Skelton's
fragmentary and allusive poem "Speke Parrot" from 1521 than previous
scholarship could perceive. In particular, as she emphasizes, Skelton rallied
against some of the contemporary Latin grammarians, especially William Horman
and William Lily of St. Paul's School, but supported Robert Whittinton,
challenging them to perceive a text as a medium of teaching through refusing to
reveal the full truth. Sarah Gordon demonstrates the relevance of food
preparation and eating in French courtly romances, which often contain comic
elements because the hungry heroes prove to be victims of their stomachs and
then tend to transgress courtly norms. She discusses these phenomena in such
works as Chrétien's Perceval, the thirteenth-century Perceval
Continuations, the Roman de Fergus,
and the Roman d'Hunbaut. Particularly the latter two works heavily rely on
culinary comedy, but Gordon does not reach a solid conclusion about why these
thematic reorientations occur in these somewhat misleadingly identified
"epigonous" romances. Does this culinary humor really represent
nothing but a satirical dialogue with the
past (29)?
Fabian Alfie unearths the remarkable topos of blaspheming God in fourteenth-century
North-Italian poetry (Folgore da San Gimignano, Pietro dei Faitinelli, Cino da
Pistoia, Guercio da Montesanto, Nicolò deä Rossi, one anonymous poet) as a
strategy by these representatives of the Guelph party to come to terms with the
ideological conflict within their own position resulting from the moral decline
of the Church. One might object, however, whether such blunt criticism of God
would indeed be the only purpose of this poetic blasphemy.
Joseph Grossi Jr. analyzes John Capgrave's fifteenth-century Y Solace of Pilgrimes,
an account of his pilgrimage to Rome, which reflects
harsh criticism of the decay and paganism dominating this eternal city, which
could also be read as a subtle rejection of the intellectual foundations upon
which Renaissance philosophy and philology were being built. Z.J. Kosztolnyik
illustrates the influence of Ivo of Chartres' Decretum, if not also
of Burchard of Worms' legal writings on
the legislation developed by Coloman the Learned of Hungary (1095-1116) who
successfully revised the laws of St. Stephen I of Hungary. John R.C. Martyn
demonstrates that Gregory the Great was deeply influenced by the musical
instrument of the organ and used it as an important metaphor in his writing. In
a subsequent article, he discusses what equipment was needed for the
establishment of new monasteries in the Middle Ages.
The two review articles describe two new books on Piero della Francesca (Donal
Cooper) by James R. Banker and Jeryldene M. Wood, and a new comprehensive study
of medieval fable literature (Wendy Pfeffer) by Alexandre Huber.
|