Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Mona Scheuermann. In Praise of Poverty: Hannah More Counters
Thomas Paine and the Radical Threat.
Lexington: University Press of Kentucky, 2002. 255p.
Vicki Ramirez
Weber State University
At the outset of Mona Scheuermann's book on Hannah More, 18th-century British
writer of social tracts, the author makes clear that her study of More in the context of
Thomas Paine's writing is as much a social history as it is a study of an individual
author. This warning prepares us for an examination of the prolific More, embedded
within her era's socio-political issues.
Scheuermann's strategy of exploring More's authorship in conjunction with that
of Paine but also in relation to other, equally renowned writers of her
time enables us to grasp the ideological coloring of More and her wealthy
backers. The daughter of a schoolmaster, More and her three sisters all have early
access to superb education, although Hannah is the most precocious. She teaches at her
oldest sister's school, and later comes to the attention of London's intellectual elite
when a letter she writes on a performance of Garrick's Lear gets circulated. She soon
becomes acquainted with some of the intellectual giants of her day, and develops
friendships that last her entire life.
More and her circle of influential friends and admirers believe in God's hierarchy
as established on earth, which "conveniently supported the status quo." According to
this scheme, revolutionary ideas in general, but in particular those relating to the
socio-economic betterment of the English poor, directly counter God's plan. Scheuermann
establishes the strictly hierarchical nature of 18th-century English thought
promoted by Church and King, and written about by such thinkers as Edmund Burke. He and
like-minded writers assumed that poverty is divinely ordained, and at best may be
ameliorated through charity, but can never be fundamentally altered.
In her chapter "Radical Contexts," Scheuermann focuses on Thomas Paine's thought,
especially in her discussion of his "The Rights of Man." In this written response to
Edmund Burke's attack on the French Revolution, Scheuermann vivifies what is at stake
for the ruling classes in 1790s England. For scholars and teachers of early American
Literature, Paine's Common Sense and other Revolutionary War propaganda will
be familiar territory. Scheurermann details the impact the book has not only on the
disenfranchised who quote its pages and discuss its ideas, but on the powerful who
recognize the danger its call to equality presents. More's immediate enlistment by
members of her circle to counter what they consider Paine's dangerous, ungodly attacks
on the status quo begins a long, fruitful career as pamphleteer, whose sole aim is to
remind the poor of their religious and moral duties.
Scheuermann also points out the centrality of the written word to this grand
"debate" between 18th-century reactionary and radical voices. By teasing
out the social structures perpetuating the divide between the privileged and the poor,
Sheuermann makes clear, for example, how education can be used "in praise of poverty":
taught to minimally read and write, the poorer classes are then fed a steady diet of
didactic teachings aimed at reinforcing the divine provenance of social iniquity.
The author devotes ample space to close readings of More's most popular tracts, though
is quick to question how genuinely attractive More's writing is to its intended readers,
considering that her pamphlets are distributed to the masses for free. More is a competent
writer with a flair for narrative, but Scheuermann illustrates how More's characterizations
are always drawn in black and white to make her didactic points as clear as possible. Her
writing betrays a particular set of assumptions about the poor: limited to simplistic
ideas and presentation, More reveals an attitude of innate moral and intellectual
superiority towards the lower classes. Her Village Politics and Cheap Repository
Tracts exemplify the ideologically driven, pedantic tenor of her "popular" writing in general.
Scheuermann's In Praise of Poverty provides a multi-layered look at
18th-century British thought, disclosing the strain that Enlightenment
ideas place on the ancient fabric of divine right and religious hegemony preceding
the modern era. Teachers of American Literature, but also of British Literature, get
a view of how revolutionary ideas emanating from North America and France influence
British rulers, propertied classes, and the writers who perpetuate oligarchic rule.
That a battle for the hearts and minds of the English lower classes is waged through
More's and Paine's writing, but also through such writers as Burke, Godwin, and
Wollstonecraft, may strike contemporary readers as unthinkable in an age dominated
by visual and electronic imagery.
Scheuermann's treatment of More and her milieu is written in accessible prose,
betraying the former's ironic eye and dry wit. She offers us a vivid, well-documented
glimpse of the stature of writers such as Hannah More, whose pen, wielded with intellect
and panache, rendered her a powerful player in 18th-century socio-political discourse.
|