Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Sandra Pouchet Paquet. Caribbean Autobiography: Cultural Identity and Self-Representation.
Madison: The University of Wisconsin Press, 2002. 345p.
Deborah Weagel
University of New Mexico
Sandra Pouchet Paquet, a native of Trinidad, has skillfully drawn upon years of scholarship
in the area of Caribbean autobiography to produce this well-researched text. She has
incorporated some previously published material, and in the preface explains that revisions
of former writings exhibit a "continuing interest in the constitutive forms of Caribbean
autobiographical culture" as well as "a heightened appreciation of the dynamics of the genre
in respect to variables of Caribbean personality and presence" (ix). Her purpose is to
examine how different and distinct types of autobiographical texts can be related, and
to explore how these works might be useful in better understanding the challenges of
diaspora and intercultural identity. In her analyses of the narratives, she takes into
account "environment and history, race and culture, class and caste, gender and sexuality,
and language and theory" (7).
The book is part of the Wisconsin Studies in Autobiography series, which is edited
by William L. Andrews. It is divided into four parts: 1) Gender, Voice, and
Self-Representation; 2) The Estranging Sea; 3) Birthrights and Legacies; and 4)
Autobiography, Elegy, and Gender Identification. In the first part Paquet discusses the
nineteenth-century narratives of four women: Anne Hart Gilbert, Elizabeth Hart Thwaites,
Mary Prince, and Mary Seacole. The Hart sisters each wrote a spiritual autobiography based
on their respective experiences with the Methodist church. Mary Prince, a household slave,
dictated her history, and Mary Seacole, a free black Jamaican woman, wrote a text which is
both a travel narrative and autobiography. Part 2 shifts to the twentieth century and to an
analysis of the masculine voice, and discusses the writings of Claude McKay, George Lamming,
C.L.R. James, and Derek Walcott. In this section Paquet "explores links between geography
and being, exile and otherness" (9). In the third part, she mixes gender and presents the
contrasting works of four writers: V.S. Naipaul, Anna Mahese, Yseult Bridges and Jean Rhys.
She focuses on the concepts of "group identification" and "cultural localization" (176) by
discussing the complexity of genealogies in Caribbean autobiographical narratives and the
quest to find space and place in the Caribbean community. Finally, in Part 4, Paquet presents
the elegies of Kamau Brathwaite and Jamaica Kincaid and explains how "both writers internalize
the deceased other" (9). She also delves into "cross-gender indentifications" (9).
Paquet successfully brings together a diverse and vast array of autobiographical
work in an organized and coherent manner. Each of the four major parts of the book opens
with an introductory section which explains the theme of that particular part and situates
various writers in that theme. Almost every chapter focuses on one writer (sometimes two),
which enables her to discuss that person's work in some detail. Yet throughout the chapter,
she draws comparisons and integrates work of other authors presented. Furthermore, she
consistently draws upon the theory and ideas of other scholars to explain, support, and
work through her own analyses. Some of the names she cites are familiar: Bakhtin, Bhabha,
Césaire, Clifford, Davies, Eagleton, Fanon, Foucault, Freud, Glissant, Gramsci,
Jameson, Kristeva, Lejeune, Said, and Spivak, to name a few. She excels as a mediator of
a variety of perspectives, opinions, experiences, and discourses, and integrates the parts
to create a whole in the final product of her book. Furthermore, she does so with a degree
of literary finesse as is found in some alliterative passages. See, for example, "communicates
the calculated cruelty of Captain" (40), "culture, where class, color, and colonialism
combine" (75), "supremacy of the white standards against a similar structure" (145),
"Mountain-Mother, magical and mysterious, whose life was marked by loyalty to her male
consort" (238), "Mrs. Drew as a devourer and destroyer of her children, who would deny her
daughter" (250), and "political and poetic principle of gay men's poetry in particular" (252).
In addition, the striking cover in variegated turquoise-blue, with an image of a
solitary shell, is appropriate to the theme of the book: Caribbean autobiography. The rich,
cool colors are reminiscent of the sea, and invite the reader into a part of the world where
the ocean is not only significant, but is also common to all the islands. The cover seems to
be a visual representation of a liquid link between a diverse population that is multiethnic,
multiracial, [and] polyglot" (141). In the introduction Paquet acknowledges a desire to
analyze the "fluidity" and "reciprocity" (8) found in the wide range of autobiographical
writings presented. Towards the end of the text, she states: "The defining element in this
study, not surprisingly, is fluidity rather than systematic coherence" (258, my
emphasis). Yet the sea, which connects, can also physically divide and separate. This is
illustrated in the title of Part 2, "The Estranging Sea." So the single shell which so
strongly depicts life by the sea, can also represent the loneliness and isolation than can
result from separation from one's homeland. The same shell can also portray a human being or
even a group striving for self-identity. Paquet writes that "What might appear chaotic about
the fluidity and multiplicity" of the various narratives selected, "may in fact be
the measure of an individually and/or collectively drawn selfhood that is straining against
constraints of established models" (8-9, my emphasis).
In terms of suggestions, there are minor errors in the book which do not detract from
its overall excellence, which I point out for the future use of the University of Wisconsin
Press. For example (and the emphasis in the excerpts is mine), on page 179, "Text,
Testmony and Gender" should be "Text, Testimony and Gender." In the endnotes
on page 279, "public sphere of it own," in note 6 should be "public sphere of
its own." These are the only two typographical errors that I found. Then there are
citations which are not exact. For example, in a passage from Jamaica Kincaid's My
Brother, Paquet quotes: "in her stone heap," "setting them alight," and "would
not be strange" (245). In the actual text, Kincaid writes: "on her stone heap,"
"then setting them alight," and "would not be so strange" (197). These, as
mentioned, are not significant mistakes, and other references checked were quoted perfectly.
This book is well worth reading, and would be of value to scholars in a variety of areas
such as autobiography, memoir, Caribbean literature, colonial/postcolonial studies, gender
studies, women's studies, and African American studies. It could be used for pedagogical
purposes as well as for personal research. Enjoy the colorful cover, and allow yourself to
be drawn into the world of the Caribbean, with its tropical island ambience. However, this
is no vacation, for you will read of suffering, slavery, poverty, prejudice, loss, alienation,
exile, oppression, and death. Don't let this discourage you, because you will also encounter
nostalgia, personal growth, pride, commitment, creativity, success, heroism, and joy. Paquet
takes the reader by the hand and navigates the way through narratives of both struggle and
triumph in Caribbean Autobiography.
|