Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Rob Pope. How to Study Chaucer.
2nd edition. New York: St. Martin's, 2001. 223p.
Rick McDonald
Utah Valley State College
Rob Pope wants his book to help readers of Chaucer do two things:
read Chaucer in the original Middle English, and develop their own
critical judgment about his poetry and how it works. Pope's two
basic goals are particularly ambitious when one considers the
heterogeneity of Chaucer studies, but I have no doubt that his
book does everything it claims. Recently, I read the 2nd edition
of Pope's text while teaching my biannual Chaucer class. Although
the book is written to be especially valuable for beginning
readers of Chaucer, it reminds any reader of a wealth of
information concerning Chaucer the Man, the Work, and the Exam.
This book is helpful to beginning students, graduate students,
and all readers who want to remember what their problems were
(or might have been) upon first encountering Chaucer.
Pope's section on "How to Read Five Lines of Chaucer" is a
no-nonsense approach to teaching students that they can extract
meaning from any Chaucerian text using just a few simple strategies.
Pope's appendix, "The 'Top 100' Most Commonly Misunderstood
Words in Chaucer," enables students to feel confident that they
can make sense of what, at the start of their reading, often
seems like a foreign language. The background provided on Chaucer
and his world and the reception of Chaucer's work is also useful
for students developing an understanding of historical context.
After the initial chapters on how to start reading Chaucer and
the General Prologue, Pope launches into an extended analysis
of how to read the Knight’s Tale, intended to show students
a reliable method of interpreting any of the Canterbury
Tales. His seven steps to understanding a tale ("What kind
of work am I studying?"; "What is it about?"; "Looking at
Characterization"; Developing the Argument"; "Relating the
Tale to its Teller"; "Seeing the Text in Context"; and "Analyzing
the Style") provide the reader with different ways to search for
meaning within any of the tales. In a subsequent chapter, Pope
provides the same questions with abbreviated answers for each of
the Canterbury Tales, encouraging students to generate their
own extended answers to the questions which most interest them.
Pope's book makes clear that there are still many engaging questions
in Chaucer criticism and gives the students a means to appreciate
the importance of the different controversies, while helping them
develop basic comprehension skills and introducing them to some of
the principal arguments surrounding each tale. The book is almost
entirely focused on the Canterbury Tales, although the
information would be easily transferable to other Chaucerian works.
The text provides some help with Chaucer's Parliament of Fowls
and other dream poems, and Troilus and Criseyde, but the
emphasis of this student-friendly text is on understanding the most
important pieces of Chaucer's work (in terms of a traditional
University setting).
Pope's chapter on preparing for an exam on Chaucer takes students
through a step-by-step argument to answer some typical exam
questions (at the undergraduate or graduate level). His advice
would certainly aid students concerned about passing a Chaucer
final or comprehensive exam. In fact, his brief outlining of
responses to possible questions would do much to improve students'
logical argumentation on any literature exam question. Additionally
Pope's chapter on "Common Topics and Debates" introduces students
to some of the traditionally important critical discussions of
recurrent issues in the Chaucerian canon across different tales
and works.
Students who read Pope's work will find an organized and thoughtful
way to develop their own reading of the Canterbury Tales and
will have a good idea of how to work with Chaucer's other texts.
Pope's style is clear and instructive while allowing students to
experience for themselves the joy of understanding Chaucer.
Students who use this text are well on their way to developing
the skills necessary to engage in intelligent scholarly discussion
and research. One area where Pope's book may seem a little weak is
its bibliography, containing fewer than 50 secondary sources, but
the exemplary texts he includes would undoubtedly be of use to
beginning students. The few students to whom I lent this text all
found very positive things to say about its clarity, level of
coverage, and commitment to issues important to students. You
can't ask for much more from a text written for readers new to
Middle English.
|