Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Milla Cozard Riggio, ed. Teaching Shakespeare through
Performance. NY: MLA, 1999. 503p.
Vivian Foss
University of Wisconsin Oshkosh
This volume, the fourteenth in the MLA Options for Teaching Series,
offers instructors committed to active learning an abundance of
practical suggestions and models for engaging students in the
theatrical contexts of Shakespeare's plays. While the title
highlights the acting, directing, and production work that most
immediately suggests classroom performance strategies, explorations
of theatrical approaches emerge from explicit theoretical contexts
and include extended textual and literary analysis of specific
scenes. Riggio includes not only essays by nearly forty contributors
-- many well-known Renaissance literary scholars -- but also
extensively annotated lists of resource materials. The book is
divided into five nearly equally long sections. It begins with
essays on the history of classroom performance and the theory that
supports it, moves on to teaching strategies and exemplary courses,
then explores the use of films and electronic programs, and
concludes with annotated guides to resources. The collection is
exhaustive, and the essays offer practical classroom exercises
grounded in current theoretical approaches to the plays from
literary as well as theatrical perspectives. There are discussions,
for example, of the unknown conditions of historical staging of
the plays, the changing dynamics of audience in relation to theater
design and lighting, and helpful suggestions about resources
teachers trained in literature can utilize to work more
interdisciplinarily.
The sophistication which weaves together theory and literary
analysis with discussions of models for teaching belies the volume's
pedagogical emphasis. Most essays explore scenes from individual
plays in extended discussions that read as if they were excerpts
from even longer journal articles. By design, this is a book aimed
to strengthen the pedagogy of courses both at secondary and
university levels. Yet this is not an introductory text cajoling
reluctant teachers away from literature and theory-based work into
prescribed classroom exercises, but rather a group of cogent
arguments rooted in historical awareness of the inherently
experimental nature of the stage. The volume offers models, but
its goal is to provide an outlook on teaching Shakespeare that
insists on discussion of the plays from the perspective of the
playwright, actors, costumers, and stage designers as well as
that of the audience, and teaching all of that actively, so that
students can discover through experiments that drama is a dynamic
art, always being re-created.
What I like best about Riggio's book is that the essays reinforce
a central premise: that the unpredictable dynamics of the classroom
usefully mirror the immediacy of performance before a live
audience. Reading silently, says Richard Schechner, reduces
drama to a monologue in which the reader is likely to impose a
circumscribed interpretation onto one editor's text as she creates
an internal, imaginative, virtual performance. While the intense
scrutiny individual reading offers is essential to scholarship,
drama -- perhaps more than other genres -- requires an openness to
the concept that a text is itself fluid. For example, we are
unable to establish a single text for King Lear, so why do we
not take this fact as an opportunity to discuss textual variants
and what they might imply for interpretation and performance?
Especially when these variants may have arisen from different
performance venues? Working through the possible meanings of a
selection of lines with students is not unlike a theatrical
rehearsal during which actors debate how best to reach their
audience. Collectively, the essays insist that if we agree that
plays are stories full of contradictions and that the sticking
points in meaning will change along with the material culture,
then students will inevitably debate meaning as they work through
planning a performance line by line.
Riggio's collection is very wide-ranging and detailed; the focus,
however, remains on teaching through performance. For many readers,
the volume may serve as an excellent review on several fronts.
Conceivably, a text-based literary teacher might review current
theoretical approaches to drama, consider a range of active
teaching strategies, and survey availability of electronic aids
to teaching and web-based databases. Because of its ambitious
scope, the book is extremely useful for anyone teaching Shakespeare,
and its readership should not be limited to the instructors aiming
for active student involvement. Some essays subtly recognize that
a teacher implementing these strategies may encounter resistance
from an internal self or colleagues trained in traditional
pedagogies. The authors address this concern by providing explicit
models or references about how, for example, to work with early
editions or to do research in theater history. The concept of
"performance" in the title is writ large -- the volume's goal is
to look beyond reading a single modern edition and to include
study of older editions, acting scripts, theater history, and
live performances.
I believe that anyone who reads through the diverse voices of
scholars who are committed to research as well as good teaching
will come to see how much they have to gain by investing more
classroom time working through passages as if rehearsing for
performance. The intersection of Shakespeare scholarship and
teaching is everywhere evident, with dozens of models for student
work. For example, one clever assignment springs from the goal
of raising intellectual issues of plagiarism as well as discussing
Shakespeare's amalgamation of sources: ask students to weave an
essay together without attribution from a collection of materials.
Riggio reminds us that students today are generally more attuned
to the passivity of television than to the interactive conditions
of theater. Getting them more fully engaged with solving problems
in interpretation may be crucial not only for encouraging their
study of Shakespeare but also will work, as they debate how to
resolve the import of some line or other, to introduce students
to the radical decentering of received authority. Thus
performance-based teaching should not be relegated solely to
drama departments, because juxtaposing various editions, different
films, and live performances -- their own as well as those of
more professional actors -- can draw students into active
understanding of the nature of contemporary study of literature.
Each section is strong in its own right and can be consulted
separately for teaching activities and guides to resources or as
theoretical reinforcement for turning one's teaching toward
performance as a way of staying current in pedagogy, invigorating
reluctant or quiet Shakespeare students, or empowering more
extensive use of technology. In part one, seven essays ground
performance-based teaching in contemporary dramatic and literary
theory while recognizing the differences between early modern and
twenty-first century theatrical conventions and staging. These
essayists show that Shakespeare will be most keenly explored by
students when they can, for example, study a play's performance
history, as Jill Levenson illustrates with the changing cultural
contexts of performances of Romeo and Juliet. She provides
helpful suggestions about how to research stage history. Stephen
Orgel links the use of boy actors with the social construction of
gender and then discusses how teachers might assign acting roles.
The second of the five sections focuses on teaching strategies,
although the exercises, as in part one, are linked to specific
plays. David Bevington and Gavin will suggest how to involve theater
professionals; Michael Shapiro discusses practical issues such as
getting actively involved in choosing one's assigned classroom to
be able to approximate Renaissance staging through using multiple
doors and moving desks and chairs. Thomas Berger, in an essay that
is representative of the approach of this book, shows how
contrasting the quarto and folio versions of King Lear engages
students immediately in dilemmas of textual history and how that
affects development of characters in performance. In particular,
section two of Riggio's collection shows how teachers can convince
students that any given interpretation is temporally bound and that
the concept of a fixed text must necessarily loosen when teachers
have ready availability of early editions, knowledge of period
theaters, and electronic access to vast amount of scholarship as
well as historical material.
Part three offers descriptions of exemplary courses and specific
commentary on how to set up performance-based coursework by scholars
such as Lois Potter. Elise Ann Earthmann has excellent suggestions
about how to prepare students to read Shakespeare, and Cynthia Lewis
offers a detailed description of how her students financed and
mounted a full production. Part four is particularly valuable for
its incorporation of a survey or film and electronic resources with
suggestions about how to use excerpts of videos efficiently.
Moreover, there are extensive definitions of film terms and types
of electronic and computer-accessed resources and how to locate
them. This section does not condescend, but it also does not assume
that teachers are aware of how rapidly on-line resources are
expanding. Reading this section is a very useful review of what
is available and in what format. Finally, there are sixty pages of
annotated guides to American acting companies, festivals with
academic affiliations, classroom editions of Shakespeare, film and
video resources and publishers' addresses. Teachers will find that
there are professional theaters with frequent performances of
Shakespeare not listed here which will also be helpful in teaching.
For example, Wisconsin teachers take students to the Milwaukee
Repertory Theater, the Chicago Shakespeare Theater, and the American
Players Theater in Spring Green. There is also the fun, although
commercial and ahistorical, of Renaissance Fairs that often excite
students to continue their study of the early modern period.
Riggio's collection is a splendid volume in both its scholarly
depth and encyclopedic range. It is especially effective in
insisting that a holistic approach to Shakespeare in classroom
performance will lead to students reading texts more closely and
to fuller understanding of drama as a genre involving playwright,
actors, and audience in which every performance can be seen as
itself research into the meaning of the play. Teachers can lead
their students into deeper intellectual and theoretical engagement
with the issue of what constitutes a text and to active discovery
of negotiated meaning in literature.
|