Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
Joel Myerson, ed. A Historical Guide to Ralph Waldo Emerson.
New York: Oxford University Press, 2000. 322p.
Cynthia A. Cavanaugh
Kean University
Reading R.W. Emerson's philosophical essays and attending his
lyceum lectures, Americans found wisdom to order their daily lives.
His opinions about topics such as the individual, nature, religion,
antislavery and women's rights now appear in a new collection of
essays, A Historical Guide To Ralph Waldo Emerson. This book
is one in a series about American authors. Each book in the series
contains both a short biography and a chronology of historical
events that occurred in context with important events in the
author's life.
The book commences with an introduction by its editor Joel
Myerson, Carolina Distinguished Professor of American Literature
at the University of South Carolina, who recently received the
Distinguished Achievement Award from the Ralph Waldo Emerson
Society. Myerson also composed a useful "Bibliographical Essay,"
which appears at the end of the book, and itemizes not only
biographies and collections of essays about Emerson, but also
books about Transcendentalism, Unitarianism, Philosophy,
Literary History, and Concord (291-309).
Myerson states, in the introduction, these historical essays "show
us how Emerson was a product of his time" (4). They also demonstrate
Emerson's timelessness, because his views continue to have meaning
for twenty-first century Americans. The introduction is followed
by "A Brief Biography" by Ronald A. Bosco and a section entitled
"Emerson in His Time," which contains five essays by Emerson
scholars Wesley T. Mott, William Rossi, David M. Robinson, Gary
Collison, and Armida Gilbert.
In the first essay, entitled "Emerson and Individualism," Wesley T.
Mott discusses Emerson's concept of self-reliance. Today some
readers may connect self-reliance to self-aggrandizement or
commercialism, but according to Mott, Emerson meant to minimize
the "predatory qualities" of man by emphasizing the concepts of
"enduring individualism founded on reflection, principle, and
ethical action" (88).
Many Americans of the nineteenth century certainly needed a man
who could tell them how to balance the materialism of their times
with a philosophical viewpoint that encouraged a union with God and
nature. Modern readers who desire to reassure themselves of the
accuracy of Emerson's rejection of self-aggrandizement should
recall the famous image of the "transparent eye-ball" in Emerson's
essay "Nature." He explains that only when man stands upon the
"bare ground" and loses his egotism will the eye-ball become
transparent and allow the man to become one with God and nature
(qtd. in Robinson 159).
In the essay "Emerson and Religion," David M. Robinson asserts
that "moral action" for Emerson constituted "the fundamental
end of religious experience" (152). Emerson counseled people to
seek an unselfish form of immortality by surrendering egotism and
contributing to something larger than the self (173). Gary Collison
also discusses Emerson's concept of "moral action" in his essay
"Emerson and Antislavery." Emerson believed that when a law of
society conflicted with a higher moral law, the moral law should
be obeyed. He stated "an immoral law makes it man's duty to break
it at every hazard" (qtd. in Collison 198). He urged residents of
Concord and Boston to disobey the Fugitive Slave Law of 1850 during
various attempts of the authorities to enforce it (198-204). Emerson
publicly renewed his convictions against abhorrent laws, and
ultimately he called upon Americans to celebrate the great success
of the Emancipation Proclamation (Collison 204).
This historical background to Emerson's lectures and writings
fosters the belief that his philosophy does not exist in a vacuum.
The enactment of the Fugitive Slave Law of 1850, for example,
served as a stimulus for Emerson's determination to write and
deliver public statements that contributed to the split between
the states leading to the Civil War. According to Collison, Emerson
allowed his image to be compiled along with William Lloyd Garrison's
and other abolitionists in an 1857 lithograph print, which
identified him as one of the "Heralds of Freedom" (207).
"Emerson, Nature, and Natural Science" by William Rossi describes
Emerson's attempts to explain nature to his readers. As a young man,
Emerson became fascinated with botany, and the exhibits at the
Paris Museum d'Histoire Naturelle. Emerson, who delighted in the
power of the mind to classify and understand nature through implied
connections, wished to become a naturalist (113-14). He continued to
analogize the relationship of the "'morals' or mind" to the physical
sphere of nature" (138). Rossi states that "specialization" of the
sciences and the demand for "professional expertise" made it
increasingly difficult for Emerson to preserve the unity he
originally represented in Nature (119, 138). Emerson's early
inspirational writings in his book, Nature, received more publicity
during his lifetime and are better-known today than his later
lectures on the "Natural History of Intellect" given at Harvard
in 1870.
Even though Emerson devoted most of his time to writing about
subjects such as nature, the soul, and the mind, he also became
involved in the woman's rights conventions by the invitation of
suffragists. He never wrote extensively about women's rights, but
he did deliver an address in 1855 at a woman's rights convention.
Fortunately, the 1855 address and the essay "Discourse Manque.
Woman," which contains some of the statements made at the
convention, will be available in June of 2001 in The Later
Lectures of Ralph Waldo Emerson, 1843-1871 (Gilbert 212, 214,
fn. 7), published by the University of Georgia Press and edited
by Ronald A. Bosco and Joel Myerson. Because of the lack of
published information about Emerson's views on women's rights,
the arrival of this book will certainly be welcomed.
Armida Gilbert, author of the essay "Emerson in the Context of the
Woman's Rights Movement," explains that Emerson's opinions about
woman's rights evolved over the span of his lifetime. Some of his
early remarks suggest a lack of interest in the movement (220,
221); however, Emerson's discussions of women's rights with the
brilliant Margaret Fuller and other activists over the years led
him to a more supportive stance (211-12). Emerson wrote in an 1851
journal that while women "have not equal rights of property & right
of voting, they are not on a right footing" (qtd. in Gilbert 213).
Following the five essays by Emerson scholars, and the Chronology
of his life, Ronald A. Bosco contributes the essay "We Find What We
Seek: Emerson And His Biographers." Professor Bosco categorizes
biographers according to the time period in which they wrote.
Biographies published in close proximity to Emerson's death offered
uniformly positive reports of Concord's sage (276). Later
biographers emphasized Emerson's "adaptations" of the thinking of
world famous philosophers such as Plato, Coleridge, and Goethe (277).
The psychological portrait of Emerson, published by Professor Stephen
Whicher in 1953, still remains influential today. Bosco argues that
"serious study" remains to be completed on the part of Emerson's
late career that has been lost to the "present generation" mostly
due to Whicher's influence of valuing only Emerson's work from the
period 1830-1860 (277-79, 283).
Fortunately the new volume, The Later Lectures of Ralph Waldo
Emerson, 1843-1871 will include lectures from the final
productive decade of his life. Scholars may question the extent
of the editing performed by the Emerson family because of Emerson's
aphasia. However, cautions regarding the editing may be brought
out without causing the work to be disregarded.
The scholars who contributed to the Historical Guide have
enriched the readers of Emerson's texts by taking the opportunity
to explain changes in his opinions over time by placing the
statements in context with events in his life, including his
interactions with brilliant literary figures as well as various
special interest groups that shaped the history of America. In
addition, the reader of this guide gains an opportunity to perceive
the historical importance of Emerson's actions that might not be
revealed within the text of his essays and lectures. For example,
Emerson's writings about slavery, read in isolation, would not
necessarily indicate the weight of his influence or exactly what
he did as a citizen of Concord to act as an advocate of freedom
for all.
|