Download the PDF
version of this article if you wish to view it or print it out
with the same formatting as appears in the print version of the
Rocky Mountain Review.
(Requires Adobe Acobat
Reader.)
The Western Tradition. A 52 Program Course on Western Civilization.
Annenberg/CPB Collection, 1989.
Peter Utgaard
Cuyamaca College
The Western Tradition is a fifty-two part videotape series
designed as a televised course in Western Civilization. The series
is part of the Annenberg/CPB collection produced in cooperation
with the Metropolitan Museum of Art. The course is taught and
narrated by the noted historian Eugen Weber of UCLA. The course
begins with "The Dawn of History" and concludes with
"Towards the Future," though, because the series was
released in 1989, some of the later episodes are already outdated.
Overall, the series can be seen as a lecture course that makes
good use of visuals. The general pattern is of lecture followed
by cutaways to narrated visuals. The lectures were taped in front
of a live classroom, although there is no interaction between
the class and the instructor. One of the great strengths of the
series stems from the productions' association with the Metropolitan
Museum of Art. The museum's vast collection provides the visual
backdrop for many of Weber's lectures. Close-ups of sculpture,
painting, and pottery are all weaved into Weber's narrative, although
not always seamlessly. In addition to the frequent use of artwork,
the series also makes good use of maps and graphics.
In general, the lectures in the second part of the course tend
to be better organized and presented in a more dynamic fashion.
Program 39 for example, "The Death of the Old Regime"
is particularly good as Weber expertly explains the impact of
the American Revolution on European ideas and politics. His metaphor
of the revolutionary process being akin to a snowball, which rolls
downhill and becomes an avalanche, also provides a simple and
understandable framework for explaining the revolution. Art, theater,
and music are also successfully included in the lecture as Weber
discusses Mozart's The Marriage of Figaro in the context
of revolutionary Europe. Episode 41, "The Industrial
Revolution" and episode 42, "The Industrial World"
are also noteworthy. Particularly impressive is the use of artwork
and photographs to demonstrate the profound changes in daily and
material life brought by the industrial age. These episodes are
an excellent demonstration of how art can be integrated to explain
complex historical changes and the Metropolitan Museum of Art's
collection allows us to view the wealthy urban middle class enjoying
life in a park as well as an impressionist's view of how smokestacks
change the Western landscape.
Weber's lectures are delivered clearly and he speaks slowly enough
to allow for copious note taking, but for a video course, the
lectures could be improved on a number of points. For example,
while Weber's main points usually become clear, they should be
highlighted and introduced more deliberately. Key words and concepts
could easily have been included as graphics to help improve the
organization of the lectures from the viewer/student perspective.
Another problem is that Weber's vocabulary is often too sophisticated,
and students (even at selective universities) will no doubt on
occasion ask themselves just what Weber means at times. Like all
good historians, Weber makes analogies and brings out comparisons
to highlight a given point, yet in many cases, Weber's comparisons
require a fair amount of previous historical knowledge. Taken
together, the above points raise the question of the intended
audience for the course. Highly motivated students with a sophisticated
vocabulary and previous historical knowledge will benefit greatly
from the lectures in The Western Tradition, but many students,
even those with a solid background in history, will find themselves
frustrated and sometimes bored with many of the lectures.
A final problem worthy of note is that some of the concluding
lessons are out of date. While ten years is hardly an eternity
in history, the producers had the great misfortune of releasing
the series in 1989, the same year that Europe was rocked by profound
changes that almost no one predicted. As a result, many of the
most important recent events, such as the collapse of the iron
curtain, the fall of the Soviet Union, and the wars in Yugoslavia
are not covered. Overall, The Western Tradition is a well
organized, effectively conceived, and visually appealing series,
yet for teachers of Western Civilization, libraries looking to
improve their video holdings, and students interested in televised
course, it is by no means indispensable.
|